January 22, 200719 yr He proved tonight that he is one of the best ever! The Colts defense has been bad in the past and their kickoff team almost cost them tonight. To come out banged up down that much against arguably the best franchise ever solidifies Manning is the real deal in my book! If he wins it all then that is icing on the cake. One of the best games ever! You couldn't ask for much more! Heck 3 different linemen scored TD's!!!!
January 22, 200719 yr Unless Peyton wins his next game, he will remain in the same class with Jim Kelly, Ken Anderson, Boomer Esiason, etc., etc., etc. The pressure will be on Manning and not Grossman in this Super Bowl.
January 22, 200719 yr Unless Peyton wins his next game, he will remain in the same class with Jim Kelly, Ken Anderson, Boomer Esiason, etc., etc., etc. The pressure will be on Manning and not Grossman in this Super Bowl. :laugh: :laugh: :laugh:
January 22, 200719 yr Manning doesn't have to win the Super Bowl for me to consider him one of the best ever. There have been QBs that are not good that have won Super Bowl, ex Dilfer.
January 22, 200719 yr Manning doesn't have to win the Super Bowl for me to consider him one of the best ever. There have been QBs that are not good that have won Super Bowl, ex Dilfer. I'm in this group as well. Marino is one of the best ever.
January 22, 200719 yr I'm in this group as well. Marino is one of the best ever. I agree and there are some that would argue that he is not just by the simple fact that he didn't win it all. You hear the same arguements in other sports as well, such Barkley, Malone, and Stockton in the NBA.
January 22, 200719 yr Now, Aikman never put up numbers like Manning has in the NFL, but he did win 3 Super Bowls and was much better in the clutch and spotlight than what Peyton has been or ever will be.
January 22, 200719 yr Now, Aikman never put up numbers like Manning has in the NFL, but he did win 3 Super Bowls and was much better in the clutch and spotlight than what Peyton has been or ever will be. And if Peyton wins a Super Bowl, then what? Where's the chink in his armor? If they win this year and the monkey is off their back, you could be seeing the Colts winning Super Bowls for a couple more years.
January 22, 200719 yr Author Reminds me of Steve Young. One of the better ever that got drilled by the media but finally shut them up!
January 22, 200719 yr If they win this year and the monkey is off their back, you could be seeing the Colts winning Super Bowls for a couple more years. He better just be happy to win 1 and see of he gets more respect.
January 22, 200719 yr He better just be happy to win 1 and see of he gets more respect. Why wouldn't he get more respect? :lol: His only blemish right now is that he hasn't won the big game... If he does, he's the king... Doesn't really matter if you like him or not.
January 22, 200719 yr Manning doesn't have to win the Super Bowl for me to consider him one of the best ever. There have been QBs that are not good that have won Super Bowl, ex Dilfer. Agreed. Ask Dan Marino still the best...
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.