December 12, 200619 yr Looks like its going to be a controversial pick no matter what because they are all so close. Hopefully one of them catapults themselves above the rest and earns a solo ROY. (I hate co-anythings)
December 12, 200619 yr Author Hey what about the #1 pick in the draft Mario Williams? He will not even win the best rookie defensive end award.
December 12, 200619 yr 1) Hester 2) Colston 3) Young 4) Jones-Drew 5) Bush I think it has to be Hester or maybe Young. What he has done is much more impressive than anyone. What has Bush done that has been so great????
December 12, 200619 yr But, if you're picking ROY, then you have to pick one...and if it's between those two, Bush is the guy. He's more versatile, he gets more attention from defenses and he has more yards...add that to the fact that Bush has been a marked man from day one by opposing defenses while Colston benefitted from being an unknown for at least some of the season....Bush should get the nod between those two guys. I disagree. What did Bush do for the 1st half of the season? Not much, believe me, he was on my fantasy team(And I'm very glad I traded him away:D ). You can go round and round about who benefits who. Bush benefits from Colston opening up the defense, Colston benefits from Bush running the ball and catching it out of the backfield. They both benefit from Drew Brees. But ask yourself this, how much different would this Saints team be if Deuce McCallister were getting all the touches? Some, sure, but not markedly so. Reggie Bush has had two very good weeks here lately, and if you want my vote for him on who will be the best player in the future, you certainly have it. ROY should be about what you did the WHOLE year though, and Colston is that guy........or at least Vince Young. Me personally, I lean toward Young because of how inferior all the talent is around him. I don't care about QB ratings, the Litkenhaus poll, or anything else, JUST WIN BABY!! Amazing to me that people still continue to doubt him. I'll admit that I wasn't his strongest supporter coming into the NFL, but IMO he's no Michael Vick(and that's a good thing).
December 12, 200619 yr I think it has to be Hester or maybe Young. What he has done is much more impressive than anyone. What has Bush done that has been so great???? I agree, what Hester has done is very impressive, he's electric, that's for sure. But ask yourself, what if all Reggie Bush had to prepare for each week was punt returns and KO returns? :scared:
December 12, 200619 yr I think it has to be Hester or maybe Young. What he has done is much more impressive than anyone. What has Bush done that has been so great???? Nothing, that's why I originally didn't even have him in it. I put him in the top 5 after post #34.
December 12, 200619 yr Nothing, that's why I originally didn't even have him in it. I put him in the top 5 after post #34. :thumb: :thumb:
December 12, 200619 yr Young Bush Colston Maroney Jones-Drew :thumb: ...Take out Bush in my top 5 & put Maroney in his place
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.