October 10, 20188 yr Worth it or no? How does it compare to Jeff Ruby's? Planning on taking the little man to the Children's Museum in Indianapolis for his birthday (and one last trip as a family of three) at the end of November and making a weekend of it. Have been told if we want to eat there, to make reservations soon. Anyone been?
October 10, 20188 yr I think it’s great. Never been to Jeff Ruby’s so I can’t compare it, but I loved my meal at St. Elmo’s. Try the shrimp cocktail. That cocktail sauce is ridiculous if you’re into horseradish at all.
October 10, 20188 yr You have to try the shrimp cocktail. It’s the only appetizer on the menu for a reason. The Navy bean soup is ridiculously good as well. As far as the steaks go, I think Ruby’s steaks are better. The steak was still fantastic though. I would definitely say it’s worth it.
October 10, 20188 yr Author I think it’s great. Never been to Jeff Ruby’s so I can’t compare it, but I loved my meal at St. Elmo’s. Try the shrimp cocktail. That cocktail sauce is ridiculous if you’re into horseradish at all. I've heard the shrimp cocktail is phenomenal, but I don't do shrimp....:idunno: :lol2:
October 10, 20188 yr I've heard the shrimp cocktail is phenomenal, but I don't do shrimp....:idunno: :lol2: Unless you're allergic, this is just wrong. :no:
October 10, 20188 yr Author Unless you're allergic, this is just wrong. :no: :lol2: Not allergic, and it's not even the taste. It's the texture I can't get past.
October 10, 20188 yr :lol2: Not allergic, and it's not even the taste. It's the texture I can't get past. More for me! :lol2: We just went to Red Lobster the other night for endless shrimp and I promise I got my money's worth.
October 10, 20188 yr Unless you're allergic, this is just wrong. :no: This coming from the person that doesn't do chocolate. That is wrong. Even if you are allergic.
October 10, 20188 yr Author Another question....Is it a place that is appropriate to bring a toddler into?
October 10, 20188 yr This coming from the person that doesn't do chocolate. That is wrong. Even if you are allergic. In fairness, I'm not big on sweets in general. :lol2:
October 10, 20188 yr Try the shrimp cocktail. That cocktail sauce is ridiculous if you’re into horseradish at all. One of my former co-workers raved about it. I never understood why someone would talk so highly of shrimp cocktail (and don't get me wrong, I love shrimp). Seeing several others saying the same on here. He must now have been lying.
October 10, 20188 yr Another question....Is it a place that is appropriate to bring a toddler into? If you have a toddler, I would suggest you go to Harry and Izzy's, which is owned and operated by the same people. St. Elmo's is an old traditional upscale steakhouse, while Harry and Izzy's is much more casual. Same shrimp cocktail (I know you don't care for this) and same steaks. Harry and Izzy's is right next door I believe.
October 10, 20188 yr More for me! :lol2: We just went to Red Lobster the other night for endless shrimp and I promise I got my money's worth. I make it a point to visit Red Lobster once or twice every time they have the endless shrimp promotion. It's gotten awkward a few times.
October 10, 20188 yr I went there back in January. Didn't try a steak as we were really only there for the shrimp cocktail. It was phenomenal. It brings a kick with it.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.