August 17, 200620 yr MLB is having fans vote on who the NL and AL comeback players are. NL Nomar Garciaparra - Dodgers Johnny Estrada - Diamondbacks Carlos Beltran - Mets Scott Rolen - Cardinals Joe Borowski - Marlins Edgar Renteria- Braves AL Maglio Ordonez - Tigers Frank Thomas - Athletics Jim Thome - White Sox Curt Shilling - Red Sox Corey Patterson - Orioles Rafael Soriano - Mariners So, who do you think the CPOY's are? I voted for Nomar and Thome.
August 18, 200620 yr Some may disagree but I think to be considered for comeback player they should be coming off an injury and not just a poor year. NL: Rolen or Nomar AL: Thome
August 18, 200620 yr For the NL it has to be Nomar Garciaparra he's having a sensational year in LA and has even changed positions without loosing a step. My vote for the AL goes to none other than Magglio Ordonez. He's recovering from 3 surgeries in 12 months and is batting .294 while on pace for 100 RBI's this season.
August 18, 200620 yr Author For the NL it has to be Nomar Garciaparra he's having a sensational year in LA and has even changed positions without loosing a step. My vote for the AL goes to none other than Magglio Ordonez. He's recovering from 3 surgeries in 12 months and is batting .294 while on pace for 100 RBI's this season. Ordonez was my second choice. Thome, to me, has made more of a contribution to the White Sox than Ordonez has with Detriot.
August 18, 200620 yr Thome has been on fire with the Sox it was a toss up for me but I had to stick with Magglio. If Thome stays healthy and keeps producing he'll beat out Ordonez in the end.
September 16, 200620 yr I'm going with Nomar and Thomas. Nomar needs no explanation, but I think everyone thought Thomas was as good as done and he has had a great year. Beltran was close on Nomar, but he had a decent year last year.
September 16, 200620 yr Nomar and the Big Hurt. No one thought he could put numbers up like he is anymore.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.