October 22, 201312 yr Author Michonne? Carl? While the comic goers have a deeper connection with Michonne I don't feel she's been given enough character development that tv viewers would fully care/riot if she died. It'd be shocking but I don't think it'd be a huge deal. Hopefully it changes as it looks like they are giving her some more development and her time with the Governor will be interesting later this season. Carl is not a character that people would care if he died and that's because of last season and him being a brat. He's seemingly changed his attitude towards Rick and others this season but for most viewers I'd imagine they still have that in the back of their minds. Again his death would be shocking but not cause for a riot.
October 22, 201312 yr While the comic goers have a deeper connection with Michonne I don't feel she's been given enough character development that tv viewers would fully care/riot if she died. It'd be shocking but I don't think it'd be a huge deal. Hopefully it changes as it looks like they are giving her some more development and her time with the Governor will be interesting later this season. Carl is not a character that people would care if he died and that's because of last season and him being a brat. He's seemingly changed his attitude towards Rick and others this season but for most viewers I'd imagine they still have that in the back of their minds. Again his death would be shocking but not cause for a riot. I agree with everything you have said here. TV Michonne is a weakling compared to Comic Michonne. And Carl is an up and down character. Sometimes I really like him and other times I want him to become a zombie appetizer. This show has become the Daryl and Rick show. Glenn to a lesser extent, and Maggie just because she is associated with Glenn. Would be interesting to see viewer response to a baby dying...particularly in such disturbing fashion.
October 22, 201312 yr I am curious to see if hoops is right about the Carol Crusade. She's becoming a bit more assertive as a character. I am wondering how that will play out.
October 22, 201312 yr Author I agree with everything you have said here. TV Michonne is a weakling compared to Comic Michonne. And Carl is an up and down character. Sometimes I really like him and other times I want him to become a zombie appetizer. This show has become the Daryl and Rick show. Glenn to a lesser extent, and Maggie just because she is associated with Glenn. Would be interesting to see viewer response to a baby dying...particularly in such disturbing fashion. It's unfortunate with TV Michonne but I think the expectations for her character may have been too much. She is such a great, but not made for tv, character that I don't think they'd be able to fully develop her the way they did in the comics. I think they've tried but ultimately they've had to steer away a lot of what made her in the comics.
October 22, 201312 yr Author I am curious to see if hoops is right about the Carol Crusade. She's becoming a bit more assertive as a character. I am wondering how that will play out. She's definitely came a long way since Sophia dying.
October 22, 201312 yr Author I do also wonder how people would take to a baby dying. I've already thought about it and I would hate it. Not because of anything other than it just sucks for the baby and the group. Rick has definitely been through a lot and if the baby died he'd be right back in another emotional spiral. I really wish they would have just had the baby die with Laurie or come out a walker. Even though there isn't much of an attachment with the viewers I want the baby to die less just having watched her playing with some red solo cups. It would just suck IMO. Would probably be the most emotional show of the series I'd imagine.
October 22, 201312 yr SPOILER********** I saw on talking dead that they based the "illness" going around on one that actually occurred in the past. The guy from the show said it affected mainly people in their prime ages. Not the young or old... So if that's the case then the baby might be safe.
October 22, 201312 yr I do also wonder how people would take to a baby dying. I've already thought about it and I would hate it. Not because of anything other than it just sucks for the baby and the group. Rick has definitely been through a lot and if the baby died he'd be right back in another emotional spiral. I really wish they would have just had the baby die with Laurie or come out a walker. Even though there isn't much of an attachment with the viewers I want the baby to die less just having watched her playing with some red solo cups. It would just suck IMO. Would probably be the most emotional show of the series I'd imagine. Why has BGP already killed the baby? :lol2:
October 28, 201312 yr What we learned tonight. Rick is back. Tyresse is whacked out. Hershel stepped up. Carol is one bad muther. What we didn't learn. Is Glenn a goner. What the role of the skinny black dude is. Who fed the walkers on the fence. Why it would take 12 hours to make a 50 mile trip.
October 28, 201312 yr What we learned tonight. Rick is back. Tyresse is whacked out. Hershel stepped up. Carol is one bad muther. What we didn't learn. Is Glenn a goner. What the role of the skinny black dude is. Who fed the walkers on the fence. Why it would take 12 hours to make a 50 mile trip. :thumb: Skinny Black Dude question and the rat feeder question were in our viewing discussion as well. Carol found Michonne's stash and has been taking her "tough chick" meds. :lol2:
October 28, 201312 yr They stepped it up on some of the Walker visuals tonight. Walker Wheel Spin Out was pretty cool. Moss grown over Skelton Walker was different.
October 28, 201312 yr I don't feel like Glenn is going to die. I think they make some discoveries next week and I am still going with the theory that someone is poisoning the water. There is way too much focus on the water.
October 28, 201312 yr I don't feel like Glenn is going to die. I think they make some discoveries next week and I am still going with the theory that someone is poisoning the water. There is way too much focus on the water. Yeah, I honestly expected to see a dead, bloated rat come rolling out when Carol knocked over the water barrel.
October 28, 201312 yr Yeah, I honestly expected to see a dead, bloated rat come rolling out when Carol knocked over the water barrel. I thought she would find something in the hose too.
October 28, 201312 yr Why it would take 12 hours to make a 50 mile trip. I've wondered that too. In other zombie movies/books, huge traffic pile-ups on the most traveled roads often slow people down, but not by that much.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.