I think we may want to re-do this thread now that Teebus has the start in NY. :bunny:

AD, over 900 yards after contact. That alone puts him at 13th on the rushing list for 2013. Both are amazing stories but what Peterson has done is unreal considering many thought he would miss at least the first six games on the PUP. He's human but on another level as far as healing goes.

No question. Peyton Manning.

Criteria is "overcoming adversity" which includes missing the season, a serious injury, or poor performance.

 

I lean Peyton.

I think Peyton is the MVP as well.

I lean AP, but you can't go wrong with either choice.

Peterson played in 75% of the season last year. That should disqualify him from contention.

As long as 1 gets MVP and the other gets CPOY, then I'm good. I'm sure AD would prefer MVP

Manning for me just because we thought he may never play again, ever. AP is a beast without a doubt, heck give him MVP or just make co-comeback player of the year to both.

As long as 1 gets MVP and the other gets CPOY, then I'm good. I'm sure AD would prefer MVP

 

Yeah, because MVP will be the best thing he can get out this season. Peyton may make the Super Bowl.