You're right, I am a Beechwood guy/grad/fan but I also know both Mayfield and Owensboro Catholic made it further than the Tigers last year and both of those teams have a lot of very good players back.
I assume this graphic is correct too (at least a correct representation of someone's opinion). A FB friend of mine posted it with this commentary:
It's so sad that we've gone from rating recruiting classes to rating transfer classes!!! College sports are out of control and not fun IMO.