As a Scott graduate I can tell you the biggest problem is open enrollment. I can name off the top of my head 12-15 kids who started and some STARRED for other programs during my years at Scott. Given the opportunity to go to Dixie, or SK or even a Cov Cath or Highlands over Scott, wouldn't you? It's going to take a miracle to turn things around. The attitude at the school in regards to the program is extremely negative, and typically the best kids have their sights set on another school. It would take a class of kids who dedicate to each other, in their NKYFL days that they will stay together and be part of the solution, but the easier choice is to go to Dixie or SK and have a shot to be good right away.
And SK's recent success diminishes Scott's chances even more...