Here's another 4 over a 1 ... Boone County beat Madison Central.

 

Correct on the seeds but this was not an upset.

4 seeds beating 1 seeds! I suppose it is a good thing that the playoffs are watered down.

Correct on the seeds but this was not an upset.

 

I agree with it not being an upset but it still argues in favor of the current playoffs. Should Boone County be penalized by playing in a tough district? My guess is you would argue they should have played better in the regular season to get into the playoffs. However, there are always going to be districts that are more competitive and this current system allows teams in tough districts a chance to prove how good they really are ... and maybe even win a state championship.

Seneca beat Marshall County, and Male beat Meade County. 4 over 1s.

So is that 4 wins by #4 seeds last night? Does that cause anyone complaining about round 1 to reconsider their position that these teams should not be in the playoffs?

VOR, you nailed what I would argue.

Keep it the same. I still say 5 classes though, but last night with all of the great 2-3 games and the handfull of 4 over 1's is enough reason to continue with 4 teams from each district going to the dance.

 

I guess it's the whole 'glass half full' or 'glass half empty' approach. I'm looking at it half full.

I guess it's the whole 'glass half full' or 'glass half empty' approach. I'm looking at it half full.

And we all know what was in Harry Doyle's half-filled glass ....

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

And we all know what was in Harry Doyle's half-filled glass ....

 

 

Don't judge, Bluto! :lol: We all have seen what you did with that bottle of Jack D when they were evicting you all from the frat house! :ylsuper:

So is that 4 wins by #4 seeds last night? Does that cause anyone complaining about round 1 to reconsider their position that these teams should not be in the playoffs?

Don't cause me to reconsider my position, with me, its not so much having a 4 seed as it is having a 4 seed that has 0 wins, or 1 win, or 2 wins. If you have not won a minimum of 4 games you don't deserve to be in the playoffs! IMO

Don't cause me to reconsider my position, with me, its not so much having a 4 seed as it is having a 4 seed that has 0 wins, or 1 win, or 2 wins. If you have not won a minimum of 4 games you don't deserve to be in the playoffs! IMO

 

Disagree. Trinity easily could have just won 4 games this year and they'd still be a favorite to win the 6A title. Keep it the same. It's as exciting as March Madness, IMO.

Disagree. Trinity easily could have just won 4 games this year and they'd still be a favorite to win the 6A title. Keep it the same. It's as exciting as March Madness, IMO.

You half way validated my point. I said if you have not won a minimum of 4 games you don't deserve to be in the playoffs. If trinity had only won 4 games and they were the number 4 seed then I would have no problem with them making the playoffs!