October 23, 201115 yr Excellent game......it wasn't a touchdown though and I can't be convinced that he definitely broke the plane enough to overrule the call on the field. I saw his glove break the plane. Not the ball. When he caught it, the ball went backwards and the defenders prevented him from definitely crossing the plane. At least in my eyes. That being said...you gotta knock it down...not tip it up. What a game....what a game....
October 23, 201115 yr I didn't think there was any question that it crossed the line. And yeah, the defense should knock it down, buy they didn't touch it. It hit a MSU player in the face and went up in the air.
October 23, 201115 yr He was 100% in. No question about it. If the plane was the end of the white, there is an argument. He got the nose of the ball over the line. Great game and even better finish. Instant classic...
October 23, 201115 yr I didn't think there was any question that it crossed the line. And yeah, the defense should knock it down, buy they didn't touch it. It hit a MSU player in the face and went up in the air. :thumb:
October 23, 201115 yr Author Excellent game......it wasn't a touchdown though and I can't be convinced that he definitely broke the plane enough to overrule the call on the field. I saw his glove break the plane. Not the ball. When he caught it, the ball went backwards and the defenders prevented him from definitely crossing the plane. At least in my eyes. That being said...you gotta knock it down...not tip it up. What a game....what a game.... They tried.to knock it down, the DB just missed it, the ball bounced off of #80 from MSU's shoulder and thats how #7 ended up with the ball in his hand. I think the ball BARELY crosed the line. All it has to do is touch white, not cross the white into the green of the endzone. With that said, I don't think the call on the field should have been over turned.
October 23, 201115 yr I didn't think the ball was close to the white line when the MSU guy had control of the ball. Not close IMO.
October 23, 201115 yr I didn't think the ball was close to the white line when the MSU guy had control of the ball. Not close IMO. Me either. It was too hard to even see the ball, how can anyone say the video proves the ball definitively crossed the plane to overrule the call on the field. Didn't look indisputable.
October 23, 201115 yr Me either. It was too hard to even see the ball, how can anyone say the video proves the ball definitively crossed the plane to overrule the call on the field. Didn't look indisputable. The field camera shooting right down the goal line showed the nose of the ball crossing. Was a very clear shot and left nothing to question...
October 23, 201115 yr The field camera shooting right down the goal line showed the nose of the ball crossing. Was a very clear shot and left nothing to question... Not to my eyes. No dog in the fight, but I will never be convinced that there was enough to overturn that call.
October 23, 201115 yr The field camera shooting right down the goal line showed the nose of the ball crossing. Was a very clear shot and left nothing to question... Did not look indisputable to me.
October 23, 201115 yr Great game and the correct call was made. ESPN stopped the play at the right time. And it was across the plane.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.