Mark Ingram

Toby Gerhart

Ndamukong Suh

Colt McCoy

Tim Tebow

Booooooo.... :lol:

No love for Suh? I'd love to see him get the award. But, I got ya GT. :thumb: Gilyard is good too.

I think Ingram deserves it, but have a feeling Colt might take it.

^I like Ingram as well. He had some big games in their biggest games, though he struggled at rival Auburn obviously. He, Suh, and Gerhart have all been better than McCoy or Tebow this season IMO.

If Tebow wins, I'll :puke:

If Tebow wins, I'll :puke:

 

I'll be right there with you.

No love for Suh? I'd love to see him get the award.

 

Suh would get my vote off that list. To do what he has done from the DT position is remarkable, and only seen once every decade or two...

^Agreed.

My ballot:

 

1) Tebow (I can't vote against him)

2) Suh

3) Ingram

4) Gerhart

5) McCoy

 

As good as Gilyard has been, he is not Hesiman worthy IMO.

As good as Gilyard has been, he is not Hesiman worthy IMO.

 

Good point. 2442 total yards and 15 TDs including time and time again willing his team to a 12-0 season just doesn't stack up... :lol:

My ballot:

 

1) Tebow (I can't vote against him)

2) Suh

3) Ingram

4) Gerhart

5) McCoy

 

As good as Gilyard has been, he is not Hesiman worthy IMO.

 

 

Why can't you vote against him? He is not worthy this year of winning the Heisman.

I like the guy, but Tim Tebow simply didn't have the regular season to deserve a trip to NYC, especially with his performance-or lack thereof-in the SEC title game.

 

I would have rather seen CJ Spiller, Mardy Gillyard, Dion Lewis, Jordan Shipley, Jeremiah Masoli, Kellen Moore, Eric Berry, or Golden Tate in New York over Tebow. Heck, I'd take Mount Cody over Tebow right now, you can't play that bad in your team's biggest game of the year and be invited to the Heisman ceremony IMO.

Spiller could have been added as well. He is a beast.

Mark had a bad game due to an injury, so all the other guys played really well all twelve games. Not trying to be funny just don't follow the other guys so much.

 

Lets look at the players teams playing in their biggest game of the year.

 

Colt won even though he made a mistake at the end that almost cost them big time

 

Stanford kid played against ND and won. Loved to seen Mark against ND.

 

Clemson player lost his game.

 

Cornhusker, lost and if he uses his head and lets Colt go they win...see Colt.

 

Gator, Tim didn't play well.

 

Folks, also Mark shares time with a kid who might win it himself someday, and Mark doesn't mind sharing time with Trent and Roy Upchurch who comes in a lot on 3rd downs. I haven't seen this part mentioned by anyone here or on TV.