I went back and watched the replay several times. What's everyones take on the Tom Brady play in which he was injured?

It didn't seem a whole lot different than when Carson Palmer got hurt a couple years ago. I don't see it as dirty.

Thats why they call Bernard Pollard the "Bone Crusher"

Part of the game. Not a dirty play.

Part of the game. Not a dirty play.

 

I agree. After thinking about it, from a defenders perspective, even if you can't tackle the QB, if you can't atleast hit them while they're trying to release, it's likely to be a bad throw. That's what I'd hope for anyways.

If it weren't Tom Brady, this wouldn't be beaten to death. I haven't heard anyone on the national sports news ask if Vince Young's hit was dirty. In fact, I have barely heard Young's injury even mentioned, except on the Nashville news. If you plant your foot and lock out your knee and someone runs into you, something has to give. Unfortunately for Brady, it was the knee.

It didn't seem a whole lot different than when Carson Palmer got hurt a couple years ago. I don't see it as dirty.

 

:thumb::thumb:

Far from a dirty play.

2 former quarterbacks (Steve Young & Trent Dilfer) both say that it was not a dirty play.

 

 

There is no doubt in my mind that it was not a dirty play.

Spygate = bad karma

No, and neither was the Carson Palmer play. This play was more dirty than the Palmer play, but it still wasn't dirty.

Anyone who thinks that was a dirty play..... doesn't know anything about football.

No, and neither was the Carson Palmer play. This play was more dirty than the Palmer play, but it still wasn't dirty.

 

You're kidding yourself.

You're kidding yourself.

 

:thumb:

It was dirty in New England, cleam about everywhere else.