^ Can we end the madness and just ask Tim if he fumbled or not?

^ Can we end the madness and just ask Tim if he fumbled or not?

 

X

Good luck they wouldn't listen to my 'plea."

He does not have control of the ball in this picture. Therefore, without seeing the play, this picture does nothing.

FOOTBALL FINALS DVDs ON SALE NOW!!

Order your copy of any of the 2007 KHSAA Commonwealth Gridiron Bowl - $19.95 per game, plus $4 shipping

Call the KHSAA at 859-299-5472 to place your order!

 

:flame:

:dancingpa:dancingpa:dancingpa:dancingpa

He doesn't even have the ball in this picture. It is already out.

^ Welcom to the debate...thanks for the tremendous insight.

You know whats funny?

 

A Rock supporter claims a photo is "conclusive" evidence that Phillips did not fumble.

 

A bunch of other Rock supporters jump in and interpret it as a done deal, no fumble.

 

All Rock supporters are happy they can now claim they beat St.X without X faithful claiming "what if.."

 

St.X supporters have accepted the result of the game. No need to discuss further what woulda, shoulda , coulda... (as evident by the lack of X posters on this tread...)

 

Many neutral folks have logged in and viewed the picture in question, nearly all, if not all, intrepret the photo to showing a fumble...

 

Pretty funny and interesting I think.......

 

ALL have a great holiday. Safe Travels for all as well.

I am calling for the immediate return of the 2005 and 2007 State Championship trophies to the KHSAA so that they can be given to the rightful owners! I don't think Ryle had a problem with 2006, but 05 and 07 were obviously not earned and should go to the better team. As with the man behind the curtain (nice Oz reference), pay no attention to the scoreboard! 2003 may be involved here too, so go ahead and package up that hardware too. Join the cause today, right the wrongs, and stop the madness!!! Who is with me? Let's do it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

This one is tired.