American Idol 5-15-2007

[pigman]

I think Blake is gone. Jordin and Melinda are both awsome, and I hate to say it but I think Jordin wins because she's prettier. Voice wise I think it's a toss up.

[RebelK]

If Blake or Melinda either one wins this, I will be so disappointed. I turn the sound down when Blake is singing and I don't dare look at the TV because his mouth just worries me silly. Melinda can sing but I just cannot get past the "no neck" and the "deer caught in the headlights" look. I just don't see any of the three being "star" quality but I can picture Jordin more than the other 2. I truly don't think that they picked the cream of the crop this year.

[UKPat02]

I hope Melinda goes home. I like her a lot, but I would much rather see a Blake/Jordin final.

[Birdsfan]

I think Melinda is the best singer ( I don't judge on physical features), but I think Blake is probably the most marketable overall. I think you'll see Jordin go the Jennifer Hudson or (God forbid) Diana DeGarmo route.

[UKPat02]

I think Melinda is the best singer ( I don't judge on physical features), but I think Blake is probably the most marketable overall. I think you'll see Jordin go the Jennifer Hudson or (God forbid) Diana DeGarmo route.

 

I agree with you about Melinda. I just think that (as shallow as this may be) she doesn't have the look of on Idol.

[spe690]

Jordin will be the most successful out of these 3. I look for a Jordin/Melinda final though.

[Birdsfan]

I just think that (as shallow as this may be) she doesn't have the look of on Idol.

Probably not.

[Devilman]

Jordan and Blake are my picks. But Melinda did a good job last night. It may be Melinda and Jordan. I say Jordan will win it all.

[cshs81]

Blake with Sir Mix-a-Lot was nice.

[UKMustangFan]

Melinda goes home!:dancingpa :dancingpa :dancingpa

 

Blake and Jordin in the finals! :banana: :banana:

[Birdsfan]

I am stunned -- never saw that coming! :eek:

 

I thought Blake had a good chance to be in the final two; but I NEVER gave a moment's thought to Melinda not being there. Once they said Jordin was safe, I fully expected Blake to be going home.

[SvFan4life]

I am actually surprised Blake didn't go home but I can see why he didn't. there are more teenage girls out there that find him "hott" and so they are going to vote for him, not to mention because he beat boxes also. Maybe not the best singer but he'll be the most marketable of the 3 that were left.

[hurricane]

I had posted several weeks ago that I liked Jordin and Blake. However, I was resigned to the fact that Blake would be sent packing. Last night was a total shock. I am glad Melinda goes home. I couldn't take that "who, me?" look any longer. Now I have my two favorites in the finals.

 

Prediction: Jordin wins by a large margin.

[Ram-T Cat Fan77]

I think that Jordin will get most of Melinda's votes. Just because they are so similar. It will be a crime if Blake beats out the 2 best singers!

[UKPat02]

I think that Jordin will get most of Melinda's votes. Just because they are so similar. It will be a crime if Blake beats out the 2 best singers!

 

 

I agree. When Melinda got kicked off last night the first thing I said was "Jordin wins".