Melinda was the best singer on Idol this year(maybe in several years), but her ripe old age of 29 worked against her in the voting. I think that Jordin will win.

Melinda was the best singer on Idol this year(maybe in several years), but her ripe old age of 29 worked against her in the voting. I think that Jordin will win.

 

 

I don't think it was age. It was appearance.

Melinda was the best singer on Idol this year(maybe in several years), but her ripe old age of 29 worked against her in the voting. I think that Jordin will win.

 

 

And the fact that she's already a professional singer, albeit a backup, played against her as well IMO...

I was shocked that Melinda didn't continue on. I know that I have been joking about her "no neck" problem and her "deer caught in the headlights" expression and if I have offended anyone by those remarks, I am truly sorry, but she truly is a good singer and I don't think she should have went home before Blake. I have loved Jordin from the start and hopefully next weeks results will leave me smiling.

Last year McPhee suffered from having the best voice but not an onstage entertainer compared to Taylor.

 

Same thing for Melinda this year. Best voice of the bunch but not an onstage entertainer. Blake while way back in the bus in voice compared to Melinda, entertains while on the stage. Jordin same thing.

 

Now put this competition ONLY on CD to listen to in the car and Melinda walks away with it.

 

But put it on the visual media of television and you have to entertain and not just sing.

 

Jordin takes it and it is not even close.

 

Sanjaya probably sells the most records of them all.

I know that I have been joking about her "no neck" problem and her "deer caught in the headlights" expression and if I have offended anyone by those remarks, I am truly sorry...

Anyone in particular?

Anyone in particular?

No - no one in particular on here - I would never direct those things to someone I really really like. It was a joke, one I shouldn't have used when talking about someone I don't know but one I would never direct toward someone I care about.:thumb:

No - no one in particular on here - I would never direct those things to someone I really really like. It was a joke, one I shouldn't have used when talking about someone I don't know but one I would never direct toward someone I care about.:thumb:

Ahh...you'd still think it, you just wouldn't say it.

Ahh...you'd still think it, you just wouldn't say it.

Well I just might think it but I sure wouldn't say it. Outside of the fact that I would never hurt someone I care for, I would be scared they'd hit me:D such as - I haven't said a word about your avatar - YET.

Blake should have gone home. It should have been a battle between Melinda and Jordan. Now, it is Jordan's to lose.