BluegrassPreps Class 6A Football Rankings 11/1

[TheDeuce]

Class 6A

1. Male vs. Fern Creek

2. St. Xavier vs. Butler (11/4)

3. Trinity vs. Marshall County 

4. Manual vs. Pleasure Ridge Park 

5. Ryle vs. Campbell County (11/4)

6. Bryan Station vs. George Rogers Clark

7. Ballard vs. Eastern

8. Daviess County vs. McCracken County

9. Dixie Heights vs. Simon Kenton

10. Oldham County at Madison Central 

[MaddenCurse44]

How does Ryle get ranked at 5 after losing?

[theguru]

Just now, MaddenCurse44 said:

How does Ryle ranked at 5 after losing?

Win or lose (especially against non-6A teams) the rankings are still based on Ryle vs. the teams below them and nothing about the close loss against CCH changes that.  

[Paul Dean]

Don’t think Oldham should be above Madison Central.

[MaddenCurse44]

32 minutes ago, theguru said:

Win or lose (especially against non-6A teams) the rankings are still based on Ryle vs. the teams below them and nothing about the close loss against CCH changes that.  

Makes no sense then Dixie should be 6.

[theguru]

2 minutes ago, MaddenCurse44 said:

Makes no sense then Dixie should be 6.

I think Dixie should be a little higher too.

[Tigerpride94]

From 5 down could make arguments that other teams are better than others but have to put them somewhere as everybody can't be #5. In two weeks of playoffs this will pretty well be sorted out. I think this is most depth 6A has had in last few years which causes debate of ranking position. In past years the 6A rankings get dropped and crickets.

[theguru]

1 minute ago, Tigerpride94 said:

From 5 down could make arguments that other teams are better than others but have to put hem somewhere as everybody can't be #5. In two weeks of playoffs this will pretty well be sorted out. I think this is most depth 6A has had in last few years which causes debate of ranking position. In past years the 6A rankings get dropped and crickets.

In my mind it is still crickets because we are living in a Big 3 world. 

[Voice of Reason]

2 hours ago, MaddenCurse44 said:

How does Ryle get ranked at 5 after losing?

Food for thought - St  X 13 Ryle 3.

Outside of Male, Ryle is the only KY team that challenged St. X.

[theguru]

1 minute ago, Voice of Reason said:

Food for thought - St  X 13 Ryle 3.

Outside of Male, Ryle is the only KY team that challenged St. X.

Excellent point!

[TheDeuce]

1 hour ago, MaddenCurse44 said:

Makes no sense then Dixie should be 6.

What makes no sense is throwing out where a team should be ranked with zero logic involved. 

To put Dixie at six: 

- Better than Daviess? Daviess is 9-1 with their only loss coming to 9-1 Owensboro... No.

- Better than Ballard? Ballard is 7-3 with losses to Male, Manual and Trinity... No. 

- Better than Bryan Station? Station is 9-1, only loss to Fredrick Douglass... No

Exactly what about that says Dixie should be ranked ahead of any one of those teams, much less all three?

[theguru]

4 minutes ago, TheDeuce said:

What makes no sense is throwing out where a team should be ranked with zero logic involved. 

To put Dixie at six: 

- Better than Daviess? Daviess is 9-1 with their only loss coming to 9-1 Owensboro... No.

- Better than Ballard? Ballard is 7-3 with losses to Male, Manual and Trinity... No. 

- Better than Bryan Station? Station is 9-1, only loss to Fredrick Douglass... No

Exactly what about that says Dixie should be ranked ahead of any one of those teams, much less all three?

I would like to see a round robin tournament with Daviess, Ballard, Station, and Dixie but it is hard to argue with your logic. 

[TheDeuce]

RPI

Bryan Station - .62930

Daviess - .59662

Ballard - .56446

Dixie - .53380

[MaddenCurse44]

15 minutes ago, TheDeuce said:

What makes no sense is throwing out where a team should be ranked with zero logic involved. 

To put Dixie at six: 

- Better than Daviess? Daviess is 9-1 with their only loss coming to 9-1 Owensboro... No.

- Better than Ballard? Ballard is 7-3 with losses to Male, Manual and Trinity... No. 

- Better than Bryan Station? Station is 9-1, only loss to Fredrick Douglass... No

Exactly what about that says Dixie should be ranked ahead of any one of those teams, much less all three?

Pretty sure Ryle barely beat Dixie. CovCath barely beat Ryle and didn't move a spot Dixie did when they lost.

[TheDeuce]

2 minutes ago, MaddenCurse44 said:

Pretty sure Ryle barely beat Dixie. CovCath barely beat Ryle and didn't move a spot Dixie did when they lost.

Make your case for Dixie being ahead of the three teams mentioned.