I'm not defending Tubby by any means, but the facts don't lie.
03': UK- Elite 8, Duke- Sweet 16
04': UK- 2nd Rd, Duke - Final 4
05: UK- Elite 8, Duke- Sweet 16
06': UK- 2nd Rd, Duke- Sweet 16
07': UK- ?, Duke- 1st Rd
The tourney seems to be the only report card for coaches and programs nowadays (fair or unfair), and Tubby has done better than Coach K in recent history.