Taking off the fan glasses (give it a try)...Wow
Looking at quality opponents, Mayfield had a record of 9-1.
Pikeville was 2-2. Their 2 wins were against 1A schools, with Daniel not playing for Paintsville, nor Stringer for Beechwood.
28-14 in favor of Pikeville sounds about right, but I think you're giving Mayfield too much credit. Especially since only one team scored more than 24 points against Mayfield all year, and they played 6A, 5A, 3A, and 2A teams.