Rank the NFL Quarterbacks

[UKMustangFan]

The Palmer discussion in the TO thread got me thinking...Let's see how everyone ranks the current starting NFL QBs...

 

I'll post mine in a bit...

[formerkywrestler]

My top ten

 

1. Brees

2. Brady

3. Peyton Manning

4. Rodgers

5. Favre

6. Big Ben

7. Rivers

8. Eli Manning

9. Romo

10. McNabb

[UKMustangFan]

1) Tom Brady

2) Peyton Manning

3) Drew Brees

4) Aaron Rodgers

5) Phillip Rivers

6) Ben Rothlisberger

7) Brett Favre

8) Matt Schaub

9) Donovan McNabb

10) Tony Romo

11) Eli Manning

12) Matt Ryan

13) Carson Palmer

14) Joe Flacco

15) Kevin Kolb

16) Chad Henne

17) Jay Cutler

18) Vince Young

19) Mark Sanchez

20) David Garrard

21) Kyle Orton

22) Matt Cassell

23) Matt Hasselbeck

24) Jason Campbell

25) Jake Delhomme

26) Matthew Stafford

27) Josh Freeman

28) Trent Edwards

29) Alex Smith

30) Matt Moore

31) Matt Leinhart

32) Sam Bradford

[Blue Magic]

No faith in Alex Smith? He's shown signs of improvement over the last year.

[jvdfc]

1.Peyton

2.Favre

3.D.Brees

4.P.Rivers

5.E.Manning

6.M.Schaub

7.Big Ben

8.Romo

9.M.Ryan

10.A.Rodgers

[jvdfc]

1) Tom Brady

2) Peyton Manning

3) Drew Brees

4) Aaron Rodgers

5) Phillip Rivers

6) Ben Rothlisberger

7) Brett Favre

8) Matt Schaub

9) Donovan McNabb

10) Tony Romo

11) Eli Manning

12) Matt Ryan

13) Carson Palmer

14) Joe Flacco

15) Kevin Kolb

16) Chad Henne

17) Jay Cutler

18) Vince Young

19) Mark Sanchez

20) David Garrard

21) Kyle Orton

22) Matt Cassell

23) Matt Hasselbeck

24) Jason Campbell

25) Jake Delhomme

26) Matthew Stafford

27) Josh Freeman

28) Trent Edwards

29) Alex Smith

30) Matt Moore

31) Matt Leinhart

32) Sam Bradford

 

Good list but Bradford will not be starting.

[UKMustangFan]

Good list but Bradford will not be starting.

 

I disagree.

 

Who else they going to go with, Keith Null?

[5wide]

My top 7 would probably be identical to UKMF's, with the exception of Manning and Brady. I'd have Peyton at the top right now.

[jvdfc]

I disagree.

 

Who else they going to go with, Keith Null?

 

A.J. Feeley.

[UKMustangFan]

A.J. Feeley.

 

Either way, they're still dead last. :lol: I think I'd rather go with Bradford though.

[jvdfc]

Either way, they're still dead last. :lol: I think I'd rather go with Bradford though.

 

I don't disagree with that. :thumb:

[formerkywrestler]

My top ten

 

1. Brees

2. Brady

3. Peyton Manning

4. Rodgers

5. Favre

6. Big Ben

7. Rivers

8. Eli Manning

9. Romo

10. McNabb

11. Ryan

12. Schaub

13. Flacco

14. Cutler

15. Palmer

[jvdfc]

1.Peyton

2.Favre

3.D.Brees

4.P.Rivers

5.E.Manning

6.M.Schaub

7.Big Ben

8.Romo

9.M.Ryan

10.A.Rodgers

 

I forgot to list Brady at #4 behind Brees. :lol: A. Rodgers would drop to #11.

[CatsCatsCats]

Mine is similar to UKMF's list with a few changes. Bradford will rise up this list with experience:

 

1) Drew Brees

2) Peyton Manning

3) Tom Brady

4) Aaron Rodgers

5) Ben Rothlisberger

6) Brett Favre

7) Philip Rivers

8) Eli Manning

9) Matt Ryan

10) Tony Romo

11) Matt Schaub

12) Donovan McNabb

13) Joe Flacco

14) Carson Palmer

15) Kevin Kolb

16) Chad Henne

17) Jay Cutler

18) Vince Young

19) Mark Sanchez

20) Matt Cassell

21) Kyle Orton

22) Jason Campbell

23) Matt Hasselbeck

24) David Garrard

25) Alex Smith

26) Matthew Stafford

27) Matt Moore

28) Matt Leinhart

29) Jake Delhomme

30) Josh Freeman

31) Trent Edwards

32) Sam Bradford

[TrueBlueWildcat]

1. Peyton Manning

2. Drew Brees

3. Aaron Rodgers

4. Tom Brady

5. Brett Favre

6. Ben Rothelisberger (sp?)

7. Phillip Rivers

8. Tony Romo

9. Eli Manning

10. Matt Schaub

11. Carson Palmer

12. Matt Ryan