December 2, 200817 yr No love for Steve Smith? Opps I left him out. I think I would place him around 6th.
December 2, 200817 yr I think you have to have Andre Johnson in the top 5, with that being said, here is my top 10.... 1) Randy Moss 2) Larry Fitzgerald 3) Andre Johnson 4) Steve Smith 5) Reggie Wayne 6) Brandon Marshall 7) Anquan Boldin 8) Terrell Owens 9) Roddy White 10) Greg Jennings
December 2, 200817 yr Author I'd put him at #11. He doesn't score many TD's and going by your first post, with off field issues, I wouldn't want him on my team anyways. The guy is a jerk and a half. All a matter of opinion of course. But I don't think he is as bad as you'd imagine, for example, the whole thing with Lucas this preseason was a tremendous mistake and everyone as moved on. Also, Delhomme hasn't been healthy the past few years. I just think Smith is a tremendous talent.
December 2, 200817 yr I think you have to have Andre Johnson in the top 5, with that being said, here is my top 10.... 1) Randy Moss 2) Larry Fitzgerald 3) Andre Johnson 4) Steve Smith 5) Reggie Wayne 6) Brandon Marshall 7) Anquan Boldin 8) Terrell Owens 9) Roddy White 10) Greg Jennings Agreed. Great WR and a great leader.
December 2, 200817 yr All a matter of opinion of course. But I don't think he is as bad as you'd imagine, for example, the whole thing with Lucas this preseason was a tremendous mistake and everyone as moved on. Also, Delhomme hasn't been healthy the past few years. I just think Smith is a tremendous talent. No doubt he's an amazing receiver but there's just always been something about him that I haven't liked so per my personal bias I didn't put him in my top 10.
December 2, 200817 yr If Andre Johnson played in Dallas instead of Houston he'd be #1... If Andre Johnson played in Dallas, he'd be the #3 receiver.
December 2, 200817 yr If Andre Johnson played in Dallas, he'd be the #3 receiver. AJ is better than TO and Roy IMO
December 2, 200817 yr AJ is better than TO and Roy IMO :thumb: He's definitely better than Roy. I don't see how you could even argue that one. And, I don't think TO is as good as he used to be, so I'd rate Johnson ahead of him right now. Not two years ago though. That said, TO is #1 in Dallas regardless.
December 2, 200817 yr :thumb: He's definitely better than Roy. I don't see how you could even argue that one. And, I don't think TO is as good as he used to be, so I'd rate Johnson ahead of him right now. Not two years ago though. That said, TO is #1 in Dallas regardless. My point exactly. And with the $ and draft picks Roy cost, he's #2. Don't mean to imply AJ isn't better than both, simply commenting on the state of affairs in BigD. Frankly, he'd be in my top 5 somewhere. I'd lump him with Larry F., Steve Smith (when healthy), Reggie Wayne, and Moss. It's really hard to rank WR's.
December 2, 200817 yr My point exactly. And with the $ and draft picks Roy cost, he's #2. Don't mean to imply AJ isn't better than both, simply commenting on the state of affairs in BigD. Frankly, he'd be in my top 5 somewhere. I'd lump him with Larry F., Steve Smith (when healthy), Reggie Wayne, and Moss. It's really hard to rank WR's. If they had AJ, they wouldnt have traded for Roy :thumb:
December 2, 200817 yr If they had AJ, they wouldnt have traded for Roy :thumb: I wish my team had AJ.
December 2, 200817 yr 1) Randy Moss 2) Larry Fitzgerald 3) Andre Johnson 4) Steve Smith 5) Terrell Owens 6) Roddy White 7) Anquan Boldin 8) Calvin Johnson 9) Reggie Wayne 10) Brandon Marshall 11) Dwayne Bowe
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.