Manual beat Lexington Catholic in the final 4

 

Actually meant any PUBLIC schools from Lexington, for the purposes of this thread I am excluding LexCath as a "Lexington School"

AMEN!!!

 

:thumb:

 

RDP

Actually Boone County is in 6A, we played them at Trinity in the playoffs last year.

 

 

duh, I was refering to WC!

Which Jefferson County team would win those districts aside from Male or Manual? Obvously not Fern Creek or Ballard because their track record the past few years proves that...PRP? Eastern? Butler?

 

If you are adamanent that the other Jefferson County schools would be dominant in the rets of the state show me one of them who actually defeated a Top 10 calibur non-district opponent.

 

For my money, the dropoff after Male and Manual is HUGE... and the next best team in Jefferson County doesn't play in 6A, they play in 3A :sssh:

 

 

Fern Creek beat Meade County who was ranked in the top 10 at the time last season, They also beat them the prior year not sure if they were ranked or not at the time but Meade County was in the quarterfinals in both '06 and '07. And LOST their first game to Fern Creek BOTH years.

 

So which is it, Meade County has an exceedingly EASY road to the quarterfinals and is way overrated all season or Fern Creek is a better team? You tell me!

 

Furthermore if youre referring to Central as the 3A team. You are correct that they are a very good team, however they would have difficulty putting up points against a 6A defense. Their defense is as good as any in 6A but their offense would fall short.

Edited July 3, 200818 yr by TigerPaw18

Fern Creek beat Meade County who was ranked in the top 10 at the time last season, They also beat them the prior year not sure if they were ranked or not at the time but Meade County was in the quarterfinals in both '06 and '07. And LOST their first game to Fern Creek BOTH years.

 

So which is is, Meade County has an exceedingly EASY road to the quarterfinals and is way overrated all season or Fern Creek is a better team? You tell me!

 

 

Fern Creek defeats Meade County in 2007 19-14, Fern Creek later loses to Ryle 55-10.

 

Fern Creek defeates Meade 21-17 in 2006, they lose to a very weak Conner 12-0.

 

Thus, I'll take Option C:

 

Meade County is the best team in the worst 6A District in the state, but Fern Creek is not much better and definately not as good as the NKY District, which has in turned been owned by the Lexington District

From '59-'74 AAA was exclusively Jefferson County schools. The city champions played the county champion for the state championship.

 

 

So then you also know the reason the rest of the state chose not to participate in a playoff system? They couldn't compete with Louisville schools.

 

Go look at the Lit Champions prior to '59 L'Ville schools 14 out of 22 years a L'Ville school was Lit Champion. Tilghman was the ONLY team in the state that ever consistantly competed on the level of the L'Ville schools they won 4 or 5 from the 30's til '59. The teams winning it were pretty much the same as today, except you would exchange Flaget for Trinity and Manual was maybe stronger.

Fern Creek defeats Meade County in 2007 19-14, Fern Creek later loses to Ryle 55-10.

 

Fern Creek defeates Meade 21-17 in 2006, they lose to a very weak Conner 12-0.

 

Thus, I'll take Option C:

 

Meade County is the best team in the worst 6A District in the state, but Fern Creek is not much better and definately not as good as the NKY District, which has in turned been owned by the Lexington District

 

Never said FC was great in '06 just said they beat Meade Cty who made it to the Qtr Finals.

 

. By your statement if Fern Creek had been in district 2 in '07 they would have likely lost to Male in the Quarter Finals same place Henry clay got knocked out. How does that prove HC is better?

 

I don't understand your rationale on the NKY district(s). Henry Clay beat one team from District (6) BOONE COUNTY and one team from District (8)that is hardly "owning" any NKY district!

 

I will give you of the teams in District 7 HC would probably be the ONLY team to give L'Ville 6A's a challenge, bottom line. This discussion was not about HC and FC it was about L'Ville 6A Publics vs Lex 6A Publics and I am sorry but you cannot convince me that year in and year out Lex schools could consistantly compete. Tates Creek, Dunbar and Lafayette certainly could not compete HC could compete but in no way would dominate