Based on what you watched today.

I believe Clemens more than I do McNamee. I think McNamee has lied about a lot more stuff on this. However I do think Clemens has lied a little bit about somethings. However as a whole I believe Clemens more than McNamee.

I think they're both liars and that makes it pretty hard to distinguish the truth in this situation.

I really can't decide,I do think both have lied about some things,but both are looking out for No.1 themselfs.

After four and half hours of watching this stuff,I'm still just as much confused as when it all started.So there you are and were will this lead to? Who knows.:confused:

If it weren't for the depositions, I would believe Clemens more. However, there are two depos, one from Clemens best friend, that were taken under oath.

If it weren't for the depositions, I would believe Clemens more. However, there are two depos, one from Clemens best friend, that were taken under oath.

 

Thats about how I feel. Pettite is really hurting Clemens chance here.

I think that Clemens sounded very scared today. I watched as he dodged some questions, one specifically about why he rehired McNamee after he fired him stating that he wanted to "go in a different direction". So right there, to me, is something a little skeptical. The whole thing is crazy. The B-12 thing was another that got me wondering about Clemens. Congress stated the specific uses for B-12 and asked Roger if he had ever been diagnosed with any of those conditions. He said "no" and they told him that was what B-12 was for. Roger then stated he started using it because his "mom" told him too? I don't buy that at all!!!

What McNamee said about Knoblach was true, what he said about Pettitte was true, why would he lie about Clemens? He's got no reason to lie.

They had a body language expert on some radio show, and apparently she said Clemens was acting like he was hiding something, while McNamee was very calm. I didn't get to see it, but I voted for McNamee due to the fact that guys like Pettite are backing his story.

For those who didn't see it, McNamee looked like a dope. Clemens looked like he wanted to bully Wixman so bad, and he couldn't so he exploded at the end. Both of these guys are losers in the instance.

If it weren't for the depositions, I would believe Clemens more. However, there are two depos, one from Clemens best friend, that were taken under oath.

 

That's how I feel too. McNamee is scum IMO but I also think Clemmens is lying. He is still one of my favorite all time pitchers. I have thought there was a good chance he was on roids for the past several years so all of this isn't a shock too me.

For those who didn't see it, McNamee looked like a dope. Clemens looked like he wanted to bully Wixman so bad, and he couldn't so he exploded at the end. Both of these guys are losers in the instance.

 

I thought McNamee looked very calm. His answers were very quick and consise for the most part. Clemens on the other hand never once answered a question he was asked... I hope they keep digging. Its time we need some of these china dolls to crack.

What McNamee said about Knoblach was true, what he said about Pettitte was true, why would he lie about Clemens? He's got no reason to lie.

 

None whatsoever. In fact, he's a complete idiot (instead of just a partial idiot) if he makes this up. He actually had far more reason to lie to protect Clemens other than the fact that he was having the screws put to him pretty good by the investigators.

I thought McNamee looked very calm. His answers were very quick and consise for the most part. Clemens on the other hand never once answered a question he was asked... I hope they keep digging. Its time we need some of these china dolls to crack.

 

:thumb: Absolutely agree with this. I am convinced that Clemens' attorneys coached him that if he got asked a tough question to simply stray off the topic for as long as possible, knowing that each Congressman's time was very limited. I assure you that had these questions occurred in actual trial, Clemens would have been repeatedly scolded by a judge for not answering the question asked of him.

I seen Clemen's lean back towards his attorney's once to get a suggestion on how to answer a simple question like "Why did you rehire Brian after you fired him?" Why would Clemen's have to ask his attorney's why he rehired him? Geez...