When healthy and in his prime...

[youknowme]

which player would you want on your team?

 

Barry, A-Rod or Griffey?

 

 

A-Rod, Griffey & then Bonds for me.

[gametime]

Junior...

[youknowme]

I understand that people will be biased on this one but I also understand how Griffey could get the nod ahead of A-Rod.

[stickymitts]

A-Rod...

 

I'm partial to infielders so Griffey's out.

On top of that, Bonds has a squirt gun.

Plus, Doug DeCinces was not an option.

[oldrambler]

I would give A-Rod the nod, almost a dead heat with Jr., couldn't go wrong with either one.

[gametime]

The way Junior played CF in his prime gets him the nod from me. ARod and JR are a dead heat at the plate when talking about their prime...

[HHSDad]

I'd take a pre-steroid Bonds.

[Goliath]

KGJ.

[ladiesbballcoach]

Griffey.

More clutch than A-Rod and better defensively than A-rod.

Better defensively than Bonds while offesively they would be a in a deadheat barring injuries to Jr.

I also believe Jr is a much better teammate than either based on the stories I have read.

[stickymitts]

We'll see in a few years. A-Rod is still in his prime...

[ladiesbballcoach]

How much are ARod's stats inflated by playing in the more-offensive minded AL?

 

Also, someone on ESPN was asking today why Arod gets such an easy pass on the steroid issue? Never know questioning his pace to hit 800 HR's and wondering about steroids with him.

[gametime]

How much are ARod's stats inflated by playing in the more-offensive minded AL?

 

Also, someone on ESPN was asking today why Arod gets such an easy pass on the steroid issue? Never know questioning his pace to hit 800 HR's and wondering about steroids with him.

Did you forget the bulk of Junior's numbers are from the AL???

 

It was Skip Bayless and he's a goon. His theory was shot down by A Rods consistency (which is a lot like Junior but a bit better at that age). There was no huge jump in numbers at any stage in his career. Just consistently very impressive every year.

[stickymitts]

Maybe Junior...

[PutMeInCoach]

Junior..

[NEERFAN]

This is a hard one, I think it's pretty even between the three. Griff is the best of the 2 OF'ers, Arod is/was a pretty good SS. With that being said I'd take the infielder by a nose.