December 5, 200619 yr Don't need inter-office turmoil. I was fortunate to meet one of the names mentioned, Gene Bennett when he was a Reds scout and he's a first class guy then and now. I agree here, with this assessment...Barton didn't agree with the Reds carrying three catchers all year in 2006, "Then (Krivsky) trades Jason LaRue, but signs Chad Moeller. So are they going to go with three catchers again? They need pitching, not three catchers." Hopefully, they can get on the same page and make the Reds contenders, but starting pitching is a must need, in my opinion. :thumb: On Gene Bennett. I also had the pleasure of meeting him several times. He was a great guy as you mentioned. His son Dave is a great guy also and was an excellent baseball player. He would have been a pro player if not for an accident that prevented him from playing.
December 6, 200619 yr He being Krivsky gave up a good young outfielder and a power hitting SS....for middle relief and an old SS who is now gone. He will never get past this IMO. This is the Dick Wagner of the 2000's.......Watch him move Dunn for a crappy starter who may throw 200+ innings but had a 10-19 yr last season. Oh but he has potential......
December 6, 200619 yr Bray developing into a consistent, dominant closer is a much bigger "if" ... bash Kearns if you wish (and obviously, you like to), but the guy is still just 26 and is finally healthy. It is the offseason...
December 6, 200619 yr He being Krivsky gave up a good young outfielder and a power hitting SS....for middle relief and an old SS who is now gone. He will never get past this IMO. This is the Dick Wagner of the 2000's.......Watch him move Dunn for a crappy starter who may throw 200+ innings but had a 10-19 yr last season. Oh but he has potential...... Come on Q... What good is a "good young outfielder" when he only averages 100 games per season? What good is a "power hitting shortstop" that averages 10 home runs per season?
December 6, 200619 yr What good is a "good young outfielder" when he only averages 100 games per season? Kearns played in 150 games last season. 5 seasons and 515 games. How was he wrong???
December 6, 200619 yr Did I say he was wrong? Isn't the point of hitting your prime about playing enough to be where you need to be? He's going to hit .270 with gap to gap power and provide solid D IF he can repeat the one season out of 5 he was healthy. Kerry Wood and Mark Prior are smashed for being Austin Kearns...
December 6, 200619 yr Injuries happen. Kearns played 150 games last year and was productive, and he will remain so if he stays healthy.
December 6, 200619 yr Did you think Joe Nathan was trash in his first two seasons??? I'm guessing two things here and I will admit that I didn't look anything up yet, but I will. My first guess is that Bray never has a year comparable to last year for Nathan. Guess 2, in all of his time w/ the Twins every trade he was responsible for didn't turn out great.
December 6, 200619 yr Injuries happen. Kearns played 150 games last year and was productive, and he will remain so if he stays healthy. My only point is, give me two young pitchers for this "dime a dozen"...
December 6, 200619 yr Will Carroll, Baseball Prospectus........from the GM meetings So far, Wayne Krivsky's not making friends. "He's signing guys no one wants and pushing the bar up." I can't print the rest of the quote from an NL official. This is from Lance's sight.
December 6, 200619 yr It's funny how Barton waited to say he didn't retire until after he received his retirement gift from the Reds, which was a new car.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.