July 20, 20197 yr I saw the earlier post along these lines that you refer to. I left it alone as I have grown to respect and agree with most insight you provide, but I can’t on this one. Mac wouldn’t last a week in a big league clubhouse. I know him very well, have a long time, but he wouldn’t last in todays game. The first time he pulled a guy mid-inning and berated then publicly after he had them run outside the outfield fence he would lose the clubhouse. The Sweet Lou’s, Jim Leland’s and others are managers of the past. It would NEVER fly with today’s game and egos. The days of leading with fear are in the past. Joe Giardi can’t even find a job after 2 successful stops, and it continues to point to not being a players manager, losing the clubhouse. None of this means David Bell is doing a good job. I think he’s much better than Price, but could do better on the little things, but to think you’d have drastic changes by inserting Mac or anyone like him is a huge stretch. If this is true, and I agree somewhat, the manager does not make a difference no matter who it is. We have been fundamentally bad under the last three managers so that is all on the players. Votto might as well be the manager.
July 20, 20197 yr The new catcher has a career night and gets rewarded with a seat on the bench. HOW does Bell not start him tonight?? We’ve become a walking talking circus
July 20, 20197 yr HOW does Bell not start him tonight?? We’ve become a walking talking circus Our announcers are average at best and when they talk about it, you know it is bad.
July 21, 20197 yr Here lately, Seems like the Reds are having a lot of trouble scoring runs when Castillo pitches.
July 21, 20197 yr If this is true, and I agree somewhat, the manager does not make a difference no matter who it is. We have been fundamentally bad under the last three managers so that is all on the players. Votto might as well be the manager. It's about accountability. There has been none since and including Dusty. Is the players union at fault??? Are you not allowed to yank a guy who makes boneheaded plays because they are protected???? Night after night this team has players who shoot themselves and this team in the foot - repeatedly. Why is that???? Over and again Mr. Me, Me, Me - Puig has shown off his arm, trying to make a big play, at the expense of the team, yet nothing changes. Iglesias hot-dogs a ground ball, etc., etc., etc., and nothing changes. If there is no accountability then this is the new level of acceptable performance and this is what you get.
July 21, 20197 yr Mac wouldn’t last a week in a big league clubhouse. I know him very well, have a long time, but he wouldn’t last in todays game. The first time he pulled a guy mid-inning and berated then publicly after he had them run outside the outfield fence he would lose the clubhouse. The Sweet Lou’s, Jim Leland’s and others are managers of the past. It would NEVER fly with today’s game and egos. The days of leading with fear are in the past. Joe Giardi can’t even find a job after 2 successful stops, and it continues to point to not being a players manager, losing the clubhouse. None of this means David Bell is doing a good job. I think he’s much better than Price, but could do better on the little things, but to think you’d have drastic changes by inserting Mac or anyone like him is a huge stretch. God knows we wouldn't want to "lose the clubhouse." We've been above .500 one day, and .500 only two days in the past two seasons to date. What's to lose??? Games, Fans, Sponsors??? I believe that if David Bell lasts five years, he will look back on this season, realize that he let his "players coach" demeanor, and cyber-metrics cause him to be an inferior manager. I also think that in five years he will have gotten back to managing the team in a more effective old school baseball manner.
July 21, 20197 yr God knows we wouldn't want to "lose the clubhouse." We've been above .500 one day, and .500 only two days in the past two seasons to date. What's to lose??? Games, Fans, Sponsors??? I believe that if David Bell lasts five years, he will look back on this season, realize that he let his "players coach" demeanor, and cyber-metrics cause him to be an inferior manager. I also think that in five years he will have gotten back to managing the team in a more effective old school baseball manner. Ironically given my last post, I agree with 99% of this.
July 21, 20197 yr It's about accountability. There has been none since and including Dusty. Is the players union at fault??? Are you not allowed to yank a guy who makes boneheaded plays because they are protected???? Night after night this team has players who shoot themselves and this team in the foot - repeatedly. Why is that???? Over and again Mr. Me, Me, Me - Puig has shown off his arm, trying to make a big play, at the expense of the team, yet nothing changes. Iglesias hot-dogs a ground ball, etc., etc., etc., and nothing changes. If there is no accountability then this is the new level of acceptable performance and this is what you get. Way off base with the Puig criticism. And no manager in MLB history is going to sit Iglesias after that play. He’s been brilliant all season.
July 21, 20197 yr VanMeter's first Home Run leads to a 3-2 Reds win. Puig does costs the Reds extra bases by just rearing back and throwing to the wrong base. He does it all the time.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.