December 19, 20169 yr I dont like it, I understand why, but I dont agree with it from a fans perspective. I think they should stick with their team the whole year.
December 19, 20169 yr He did spend the whole year with his team. Bowl games are nothing more than exhibition games if you aren't in the playoffs. Ask Jalen Smith if it's a good idea to play in these.
December 19, 20169 yr Author He did spend the whole year with his team. Bowl games are nothing more than exhibition games if you aren't in the playoffs. Ask Jalen Smith if it's a good idea to play in these. The bowl game counts IMO as the whole year. If its the Nat Champ Bowl does he still sit out?
December 19, 20169 yr The bowl game counts IMO as the whole year. If its the Nat Champ Bowl does he still sit out? I wouldn't think so because that game has meaning. You play to win a title. If you make the playoffs your season isn't over. What exactly does the Hyundai Sun Bowl against UNC mean in the bigger picture? It's about risk reward. Why risk being Jalen Smith if there is no reward?
December 19, 20169 yr The bowl game counts IMO as the whole year. If its the Nat Champ Bowl does he still sit out? No.
December 19, 20169 yr Author No. IMO it does. I assume all SRs that have draft expectation should just not play a Bowl Game.
December 19, 20169 yr It's up to the player. I have no issue if they play and have no issue if they don't play. Again, why take the risk for a nothing game?
December 19, 20169 yr This will continue to happen more and more and I don't blame the kids one bit. It's absolutely not worth it to risk your NFL career on one game that means absolutely nothing if you're not playing for a National Championship.
December 19, 20169 yr Side note: I didn't realize Christian McCaffery's dad was THAT Ed McCaffery until they brought it up during the Patriots/Broncos game yesterday. Good genes helps. :lol2:
December 19, 20169 yr Author This will continue to happen more and more and I don't blame the kids one bit. It's absolutely not worth it to risk your NFL career on one game that means absolutely nothing if you're not playing for a National Championship. Half or more of his season was spent playing for nothing then because they were never in the hunt for a playoff. Why did he finish the season and not just take it off too?
December 19, 20169 yr This will continue to happen more and more and I don't blame the kids one bit. It's absolutely not worth it to risk your NFL career on one game that means absolutely nothing if you're not playing for a National Championship. I agree. BUT I want to also note that its always been that way, even 50 years ago. Only 3 or 4 teams knew they had a chance to be named national champs. Back in the day it was done as a media vote, many times naming unjustified national Champs due to the political landscape of the sport. But most teams in bowls knew they weren't going to be named national champ due to a win in their bowl. The playoffs haven't changed that situation.
December 19, 20169 yr I say I get it but I'm can't say if I'd do it. It would be tough to walk away from teammates.
December 19, 20169 yr IMO it does. I assume all SRs that have draft expectation should just not play a Bowl Game. Most of those seniors would play because it will potentially allow them to increase their draft stock. That isn't the case here. Don't blame him one bit for sitting out.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.