I'm starting this poll because some feel that success is based on head to head matchups, while some tend to look at overall success. So I figured I would put it up to a vote, and let BGP nation decide.

I'm all about rings and things.

Belfry defeated Johnson Central in 2007, 2008, and 2012.

 

Johnson Central defeated Belfry in 2009, 2010, 2011, 2013, and 2014.

You can make this 100 to 1 for Belfry and against Johnson Central but the fact remains that Johnson Central is the King of the East because of its head-to-head success against Belfry over the previous 8 seasons.

Again, you are not specific in your thread title.

Belfry defeated Johnson Central in 2007, 2008, and 2012.

 

Johnson Central defeated Belfry in 2009, 2010, 2011, 2013, and 2014.

 

BG and Highlands will be in 5A together for the next 4 years. If BG wins state twice which school has a better program?

Again, you are not specific in your thread title.

 

Who has a better program? BG or Mayfield?

"Success" can be defined many ways. I don't think championship rings defines it. What Iroquois did this year, given their circumstances, is "success." If they sustain it, we can talk about them.

 

If you are looking at the whole picture, and really make it 15 years, I don't know how anyone can argue with the kind of program that Louisville Central and Coach Scoggins has built.

BG and Highlands will be in 5A together for the next 4 years. If BG wins state twice which school has a better program?

 

Will they play head-to-head during the regular season during this 4 year span, as well?

 

If not, we will have to wait and see how both teams do over the next 4 post-seasons.

Again, you are not specific in your thread title.

 

The poll spells it out, but once again you're right. I have kids, I should know better.

I didn't see the poll, so apparently I got off-topic. Sorry. I'll go with Belfry.

Will they play head-to-head during the regular season during this 4 year span, as well?

 

If not, we will have to wait and see how both teams do over the next 4 post-seasons.

 

Doubt it but you never know. I'd love that matchup in the regular season but with them in the same class I wouldn't expect it. If they meet it will likely be in the state finals.

The poll spells it out, but once again you're right. I have kids, I should know better.

 

You also are a great candidate for the College Football Playoff Selection Committee. They cannot get it right either with head-to-head matchups.

Doubt it but you never know. I'd love that matchup in the regular season but with them in the same class I wouldn't expect it. If they meet it will likely be in the state finals.

 

Would love to see them play against each other all 4 years.

Would love to see them play against each other all 4 years.

 

Me too. BG will win at least two of those matchups IMO.