I have always liked VB when she married Eddie Van Halen it just about turned me against Van Halen. I grew out of that. :lol:

Valerie.

I agree, VB's picture is for magazine cover (airbrushed) and Mariah's is a picture taken while she was on the beach and did not know was it was coming.

 

And, without makeup.

 

Sorry, old-timers. I loved "One Day At A Time" when it was on, and love VB as a classic girl-next-door type, but Mariah Carey is smokin' hot (despite her loopyness).

Mimi is whacked, plain and simple.

 

We're judging her looks, not her mental state. :ohbrother:

I used to be a big "fan" of Mariah. But that was about 10 years, 100 pounds, and countless medications ago. Now it's not even a contest. Valerie wins easily...and does it at 48 years old, which is absolutely amazing!

I can't believe no one went with Mariah until the 12th post.

 

You have got to be kidding me.

This should not even be close but I'm afraid it will.

 

Turns out, it isn't close. :ohbrother::idunno:

 

So much for the old saying that 50 million Elvis fans can't be wrong...

Mariah.

 

And just to keep it fair . . .

We're judging her looks, not her mental state. :ohbrother:

Sorry 5, I just can't separate the two. Not to mention, Valerie was the cream of the crop when I was "younger". To see her look that good at that age is bell ringer for me. You can have MiMi and her inflatables.

Sorry 5, I just can't separate the two. Not to mention, Valerie was the cream of the crop when I was "younger". To see her look that good at that age is bell ringer for me. You can have MiMi and her inflatables.

 

One could almost get the impression from your post that you have a problem with "inflatables"???? Maybe it's just me, but I don't see their harm on society. : :sssh: :laugh:

Sorry 5, I just can't separate the two. Not to mention, Valerie was the cream of the crop when I was "younger". To see her look that good at that age is bell ringer for me. You can have MiMi and her inflatables.

 

We're not asking if who you'd rather date/marry. Purely aesthetic quality.

 

And I don't know one way or another if Mariah actually has been enhanced. I had her debut album when it first came out, and I recall her being blessed even then, when she was about 17-18. I may be wrong, because I've not paid that close attention to her since then.

Valerie!!! Oh to be a teenager again in the late 70"s. I think I'll go watch TV Land.:lol::lol:

:thumb: I hear you brd, I hear you!

BTW, VB is 48 years old.

Yep! :ylsuper:. Val at 48 has it all over MC, not even close.

Valerie is not even close to being in the same league as Mariah. That is a terrible picture of Mariah and a good picture of Valerie.

There is a reason why the pic of Valerie is better than Mariah's pic. A very simple one, she is much better looking.

We're not asking if who you'd rather date/marry. Purely aesthetic quality.

 

And I don't know one way or another if Mariah actually has been enhanced. I had her debut album when it first came out, and I recall her being blessed even then, when she was about 17-18. I may be wrong, because I've not paid that close attention to her since then.

Come on James!!!!

I had her debut album when it first came out, and I recall her being blessed even then, when she was about 17-18.

In her first video, she was a bean pole.

Come on fella's you have got to be kidding me...Valerie looks excellent for her age, and yes I was more than anamored with her when I was growing up, but to compare with Mariah now...Come on!!!!