Come on, folks. CCH had a down year yet they would have kicked the Tigers from Park Hills back to B-town.

 

If you're "rewarding" them for something, fine. If you think B-town was better....yikes.

 

Are you referring to Beechwood???

For comparative purposes:

 

Like opponents for CCH & Bellevue

 

CCH versus -

NCC W 38-34

Beechwood L 35-21

 

Bellevue versus-

NCC L 42-6

Beechwood L 48-0

 

I believe that when we are comparing top 10, we are saying who the best 10 teams are if they played each other. I believe Bellevue was getting consideration of how they did in their District, which is not comparative.

For comparative purposes:

 

Like opponents for CCH & Bellevue

 

CCH versus -

NCC W 38-34

Beechwood L 35-21

 

Bellevue versus-

NCC L 42-6

Beechwood L 48-0

 

I believe that when we are comparing top 10, we are saying who the best 10 teams are if they played each other. I believe Bellevue was getting consideration of how they did in their District, which is not comparative.

 

 

Why let facts get in the way of a good CovCath bashing...

Why let facts get in the way of a good CovCath bashing...

 

I believe that he was making your point for you.

I'm really getting a kick out of this debate:lol:

1.HHS

2.NCC

3.SK

4.Beechwood

5.Boone Co.

6.Conner

7.Cov Cath

8.Dixie

9.Ryle

10.Campbell Co.

 

:thumb:

:thumb:

 

You dissin the alma mater??

I believe that he was making your point for you.

 

Yes, he was. And I was agreeing with him.

 

:thumb:

Why let facts get in the way of a good CovCath bashing...

 

I'm not sure where anyone has "bashed" CCH. So I left them out of my top ten, but included the caveat that I don't have any issue with putting them at #10. And I won't disagree that they'd beat Bellevue, so ultimately I guess my list was flawed. It just kind of weighed on me that CCH had such a poor year.

 

But it's equally off base for someone to rank them #7. Ryle should be ahead of both them and Dixie.

I'm really getting a kick out of this debate:lol:

 

:lol: Quite sad that we CovCath fans have been forced to debate about who is better, CovCath or Bellevue.

:lol: Quite sad that we CovCath fans have been forced to debate about who is better, CovCath or Bellevue.

 

Don't give up an average 50 points a game and it'll never occur. :laugh:

 

And, yes, that is a joke only.

Are you referring to Beechwood???

 

Uh, no.

But it's equally off base for someone to rank them #7. Ryle should be ahead of both them and Dixie.

 

Agreed.

I was debating between Bellevue/Holy Cross/Cov Cath for the last spot. I just felt that CCH had such a down year that Bellevue was more deserving, but I would not put up much of an argument if someone wants to claim either of the other two should be there instead of the Tigers.

 

In looking at Humped Camels' list, I will say that I most definitely think Ryle should go before Dixie and CCH has no business at all in the #7 spot.

 

Why do you definitely think that? I am not a Cov Cath fan but they played a brutal schedule and beat NCC and Dixie. Plus, they won a playoff game, so how you think Dixie should be ahead of them is very confusing to me. Ryle staggered across the finished line and lost thier playoff game...It's all opinioned based but I don't think my opinions are unsound.

In all honesty none of the teams I ranked 7-10 belong on any top list. Odd year for NKY football.