Pujols or A-Rod?

[thebigfella23]

If your starting a team today and you have to pick between Pujols or A-Rod whose it gonna be?

[saint4]

ARod is a horrible team mate and does not win, I will take Pujols over him any day. Plus Pujols hits in the postseason.

[beleiveinblue54]

A-rod

[thebigfella23]

A-rod

 

Why A-rod?

[born2reign]

A-Rod as a SS...he is still the best talent in baseball. Heck, I would even take A-Rod as a 3B. I love the guy!

[Baseballguy]

A-Rod

Matt Holliday

Jose Reyes

Jimmy Rollins

Albert Pujols

[FairFan]

Pujols

[AverageJoesGym]

Pujols by a bunch. He's got a World Series Ring--A-Rod doesn't. For the people that want to play A-Rod at SS that is just a pipe dream at this point. You could play him there but he'd be one of the 6-7 worst defensive players at that position. Plus he comes up small when it matter most. I'm glad he's a Yankee.

[thebigfella23]

A-Rod

Matt Holliday

Jose Reyes

Jimmy Rollins

Albert Pujols

 

The one thing that every single player you have on the list(besides pujols) is they dont have a ring!!

[stickymitts]

ARod is a horrible team mate and does not win, I will take Pujols over him any day. Plus Pujols hits in the postseason.

 

I've heard the same about Pujols...

 

To say he doesn't win is weak. Pitching dominates the game and he only occupies one position in the lineup.

 

I guess Dan Marino's a loser too...

[thebigfella23]

I've heard the same about Pujols...

 

To say he doesn't win is weak. Pitching dominates the game and he only occupies one position in the lineup.

 

I guess Dan Marino's a loser too...

 

You have heard the same about Pujols? From who reds or cubs fans? Pujols is a great teammate. Everyone in that clubhouse loves him. He gets along with Larussa.

 

Yeah A-Rod has all the chances in the world to win. What about this year? He had atleast 4 at bats with runners in scoring position in the ALDS game vs cleveland. I would know. I was there.:sssh:

[stickymitts]

You have heard the same about Pujols? From who reds or cubs fans? Pujols is a great teammate. Everyone in that clubhouse loves him. He gets along with Larussa.

 

Yeah A-Rod has all the chances in the world to win. What about this year? He had atleast 4 at bats with runners in scoring position in the ALDS game vs cleveland. I would know. I was there.:sssh:

 

Actually it was from the media. He's a butt to them too...

 

So the Yanks only had one out per inning? Kind of unfair...

[AverageJoesGym]

I've heard the same about Pujols...

 

To say he doesn't win is weak. Pitching dominates the game and he only occupies one position in the lineup.

I guess Dan Marino's a loser too...

 

What about the fact that both the Mariners and Rangers record improved the season after he left those two teams? Or the fact that the Yankees had been to the World Series 6 out of 7 years before he got there but have yet to make it with him in Pinstripes?

[thebigfella23]

Actually it was from the media. He's a butt to them too...

 

So the Yanks only had one out per inning? Kind of unfair...

 

Yeah b/c they accused pujols of using steriods. How would you react. Thsat was to one station to buddy.

 

No they had three like every other team in the history of baseball. But when your paying a guy like a rod the money he is getting, he needs to hit in atleast one of those situations. There is no excuse for that.

[stickymitts]

If the reason you pick Pujols is because you'll have more money to pay for other players, then I guess that works. Seems to me you'd want to build your team around the best player though...after pitching...