January 16, 200818 yr This is a hard one, if you are looking at over all numbers, Farve is tops but Brady's winning percentage is out of this world but if he can continue to play at this pace for a few more seasons he'll have a fine body of work with titles and numbers.
January 17, 200818 yr Author Im like you Neerfan, its hard to say. Brady has 3 Rings and the 4th seems to be inevitable, a 19-0 season and a great winning percentage. On the other hand Favre has all kinds of records, including the games played which is very impressive.
January 17, 200818 yr You can nor go wrong with either. Neither has really had very many HOFers on the offensive side of the ball (with the exception of this year for Brady.) I am going to have to go with Favre because he has sustained it longer and had better passing numbers with very little talent on his side of the ball.
January 17, 200818 yr You can't go wrong with Brett Favre. Although Brady has the rings, I don't see anyone lasting as long as Favre has. The thought of him even coming back next season is remarkable in itself.
January 17, 200818 yr Author Bradys games played streak is not nearly as long as Bretts but its still impressive. Im not sure what exactly it is, but I dont think he has missed a game in a while.
January 17, 200818 yr Favre could beat up Brady. Therefore he's had the better everything. :laugh::laugh: Since that I am a HUGE Favre fan and can't stand pretty boy Brady. I agree! (and would love to see that happen ) I do seriously think that right now anyway it is Favre, with the records that he holds and is still breaking/setting new ones imo he could possibly be considered the best ever. Depending on how long Brady plays and what all records/title that he /his teams win in the future that may change. Right now my vote goes to Brett Favre.
January 17, 200818 yr This is like asking which is better, Brady or Brohm. One's in the Winter of his career, one is essentially in the Spring of his career. I don't think it's possible to compare the two. I'll tell you this much...I'm praying for a Packers/Patriots Superbowl, though. Two of the best head to head....And two teams I really respect. I am praying....
January 17, 200818 yr Rockmom....I hope to God in about 8 years we are having that same conversation :ylsuper:
January 17, 200818 yr Rockmom....I hope to God in about 8 years we are having that same conversation :ylsuper: Me too! I'm trying to project into the future! :banana:
January 17, 200818 yr I love Favre but I think he would be the first to tell you he would trade all the records for the two additional rings Brady already has.
January 17, 200818 yr It seems that a few people have preconcieved notions about both Brady and Favre. I'll ask the question another way. Who is a better QB Marino or Montana? Same debate, different era. In the end, Brady will have numbers to match Favre and a whole hand full of Super Bowl rings that Favre doesn't have. To me, he may go down as the best ever.........
January 17, 200818 yr It seems that a few people have preconcieved notions about both Brady and Favre. I'll ask the question another way. Who is a better QB Marino or Montana? Same debate, different era. In the end, Brady will have numbers to match Favre and a whole hand full of Super Bowl rings that Favre doesn't have. To me, he may go down as the best ever......... IMO, Montana.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.