July 23, 200719 yr Here's some stats: Slaton 248 Rushes, 1744 yards, 7.0 avg, 16 TD, Longest Run = 65 yds 27 Receptions, 360 yards, 13.3 avg, 2 TD, Longest Rec = 67 yds McFadden 284 Rushes, 1647 yards, 5.8 avg, 14 TD, Longest Run = 80 yds 11 Receptions, 149 yards, 13.5 avg, 1 TD, Longest Rec = 70 yds Neither player even fumbled the ball, much less lost one. If I'm not mistaken, I thought Slaton fumbled a few times there at the end of the season when he injuried his arm. :confused:
July 23, 200719 yr If I'm not mistaken, I thought Slaton fumbled a few times there at the end of the season when he injuried his arm. :confused: I know he put it on the ground twice against UL...
July 23, 200719 yr WOW! Try going by the college football games on saturdays, the teams they play on, bowl games, or even the Heisman voting. It was kind-of self-explanatory don't you think? Listen, if you can honestly sit there and think that everyone here on BGP knows watched every game of McFadden's or Slaton, and knows everyone of their stats then more power to ya, but I can guarantee that we know some of it, but to sit there and think that you can start a thread and say "go" as a starting point then that's your opinion, but as you can see other posters have filled in the blanks by providing stats, I'm just saying it's a lot easier and more helpful if you do it to begin with when comparing to athletes.:thumb:
July 23, 200719 yr I know he put it on the ground twice against UL... Good, I'm not crazy. I knew it was in a big game, I just couldn't remember if it was UL or Rutgers.
July 23, 200719 yr Since McFadden played in the SEC who according to some had the the most horrible defense in the country I'll go with Slayton.:lol:
July 23, 200719 yr If I'm not mistaken, I thought Slaton fumbled a few times there at the end of the season when he injuried his arm. :confused: I thought I remembered seeing him fumble, but figured I must have been wrong when I looked at the stats from espn.com...either that, or I misread the stats. :thumb:
July 23, 200719 yr Since McFadden played in the SEC who according to some had the the most horrible defense in the country I'll go with Slayton.:lol: :laugh: :laugh: :laugh: Lord you should apologize.
July 24, 200719 yr Author Listen, if you can honestly sit there and think that everyone here on BGP knows watched every game of McFadden's or Slaton, and knows everyone of their stats then more power to ya, but I can guarantee that we know some of it, but to sit there and think that you can start a thread and say "go" as a starting point then that's your opinion, but as you can see other posters have filled in the blanks by providing stats, I'm just saying it's a lot easier and more helpful if you do it to begin with when comparing to athletes.:thumb: Voice your opinion or not. Doesn't matter. This isn't growing together preschool. It's a thread about two players that play college football in, guess what, a college football thread. Either you know about them and will post or you don't and will still post your opinion or not. TV and the internet have this funny way of showing stats or whatever else you are talking about. You really do have other options than what you are trying to do right now.:thumb:
July 24, 200719 yr Voice your opinion or not. Doesn't matter. This isn't growing together preschool. It's a thread about two players that play college football in, guess what, a college football thread. Either you know about them and will post or you don't and will still post your opinion or not. TV and the internet have this funny way of showing stats or whatever else you are talking about. You really do have other options than what you are trying to do right now.:thumb: Pretty simple protocol that we have here at BGP. When starting a thread like this, you give your opinion and make your case...
July 24, 200719 yr Pretty simple protocol that we have here at BGP. When starting a thread like this, you give your opinion and make your case... And provide stats when needed!
July 24, 200719 yr Pretty simple protocol that we have here at BGP. When starting a thread like this, you give your opinion and make your case... That is generally the way of things. :thumb:
July 24, 200719 yr Author Pretty simple protocol that we have here at BGP. When starting a thread like this, you give your opinion and make your case... It's been that way FOREVER.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.