October 23, 200619 yr yep... when Sam came off the field so did Dexter, so that is a good indicator... is it any coincidence that the Panthers always had 60 yards rushing with Dexter in there? he is KEY... It's amazing how good the defense is with Dexter in there. :ylsuper:
October 23, 200619 yr Palmer was far from way off in the second half.Yes, he was. At this level, when I say way off, I don't mean he was throwing a county in the wrong direction. Off is when the balls are consistantly placed just past the finger tips of the recievers. Way off is when the balls are completely uncatchable. What about that ball that was a perfect throw to the corner back, if he had just turned around to catch it? He was way off.
October 23, 200619 yr Yes, he was. At this level, when I say way off, I don't mean he was throwing a county in the wrong direction. Off is when the balls are consistantly placed just past the finger tips of the recievers. Way off is when the balls are completely uncatchable. What about that ball that was a perfect throw to the corner back, if he had just turned around to catch it? He was way off. That was a bad pass but I wouldn't say Palmer was way off.
October 23, 200619 yr Yes, he was. At this level, when I say way off, I don't mean he was throwing a county in the wrong direction. Off is when the balls are consistantly placed just past the finger tips of the recievers. Way off is when the balls are completely uncatchable. What about that ball that was a perfect throw to the corner back, if he had just turned around to catch it? He was way off. :lol: If that's the logic you want to use. Carson was pretty solid in the second half IMO. Came up with many key throws.
October 23, 200619 yr :lol: If that's the logic you want to use. Carson was pretty solid in the second half IMO. Came up with many key throws.He had some throws that were nice that stuck out because they were important and pretty breathtaking. It's sorta like Patrick Sparks... If he hits the clutch three at the end of the game, but was 1 for 9 before that, is it fair to say that he was off? Yup.
October 23, 200619 yr He had some throws that were nice that stuck out because they were important and pretty breathtaking. It's sorta like Patrick Sparks... If he hits the clutch three at the end of the game, but was 1 for 9 before that, is it fair to say that he was off? Yup. But that isn't what happened. I think he had a couple of bad throws that are sticking out in your mind... 23 for 39, 240 yards and 2 TD's is a solid game.
October 23, 200619 yr But that isn't what happened. I think he had a couple of bad throws that are sticking out in your mind... 23 for 39, 240 yards and 2 TD's is a solid game.Didn't I say in my first post that I was talking about a pretty limited portion of the game? 1.5 quarters is only 3/8s of a game, and for that 3/8s he was off, overthrowing his man on what should have been easy TDs or big gainers.
October 23, 200619 yr Didn't I say in my first post that I was talking about a pretty limited portion of the game? 1.5 quarters is only 3/8s of a game, and for that 3/8s he was off, overthrowing his man on what should have been easy TDs or big gainers. The second half was his better half though. Anyways, as a Bengals fan, I liked the CP I saw yesterday.
October 23, 200619 yr Didn't I say in my first post that I was talking about a pretty limited portion of the game? 1.5 quarters is only 3/8s of a game, and for that 3/8s he was off, overthrowing his man on what should have been easy TDs or big gainers. If what you watched was the 1st half, I'd be with you. But you are blasting the portion of the game he played well. It doesn't add up...
October 23, 200619 yr If what you watched was the 1st half, I'd be with you. But you are blasting the portion of the game he played well. It doesn't add up...All I know is what I saw, which was Carson completing a lot of short stuff where TJ and others made the play with their feet and the one VERY nice throw to Chad, but missing his man down field when the Bengals were taking their shots. He had time on those throws. The plays were the right calls. The players were open. He made the right reads. But when the play was done they were incompletes because he was overthrowing his man consistantly.
October 23, 200619 yr All I know is what I saw, which was Carson completing a lot of short stuff where TJ and others made the play with their feet and the one VERY nice throw to Chad, but missing his man down field when the Bengals were taking their shots. He had time on those throws. The plays were the right calls. The players were open. He made the right reads. But when the play was done they were incompletes because he was overthrowing his man consistantly. So you had a problem with all 10 incomplete passes in the 2nd half. Right...
October 23, 200619 yr All I know is what I saw, which was Carson completing a lot of short stuff where TJ and others made the play with their feet and the one VERY nice throw to Chad, but missing his man down field when the Bengals were taking their shots. He had time on those throws. The plays were the right calls. The players were open. He made the right reads. But when the play was done they were incompletes because he was overthrowing his man consistantly. He had a few overthrows. The one to Chad was an awful pass because he was covered man to man and we should have made that hurt. However, the dowfield threat opened up the TE's and short passing. I can't understand giving the WR's credit when you aren't giving Palmer any.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.