Beach, hands down, next question.

Gross was great at Russell and West was an absolute men playing amongst boys. West was so much fun to watch.

:thumb: Imo west was much better than Gross, but I don't think either of them could be compared with Beach, just imo.

Beach without a doubt!

IYO who is the best.

 

Flip my man,

 

You asked this question and opened us(ME) up to scorn from those who disagree:sssh:

how about giving us "your" overview of it

 

Thanks,

Woody Jr

The answer to this question is Arliss Beach. Its not even close, I would take Arliss at 75% over Blume at 150%.

The answer to this question is Arliss Beach. Its not even close, I would take Arliss at 75% over Blume at 150%.

:thumb: :thumb: and that is not saying it to put down Blume.

The answer to this question is Arliss Beach. Its not even close, I would take Arliss at 75% over Blume at 150%.

 

Saying that Beach was better is one thing, and I believe is accurate. I have seen them both play. However, saying that you would take a very good back only at 75% of his abilities over another very good back even if he were 50% better than he already is, ... that is just crazy talk. Beach was better, but given your scenario, I would take Blume. Anything else is just showing too much bias towards a player from your school. Beach was better, but not twice as good as Blume.

:thumb: :thumb: and that is not saying it to put down Blume.

 

But that is exactly what it does.

Isn't Beach currently with the Packers right now?

A better question would be West or Beach but Beach is still the better back. Beach played behind an average o-line, everyone knew he was going to get the ball and still put up amazing stats. West ran behind a good o-line with multiple weapons. Ask the JC fans if they remember the season opener against Ashland during Beach's senior year?

A better question would be West or Beach but Beach is still the better back. Beach played behind an average o-line, everyone knew he was going to get the ball and still put up amazing stats. West ran behind a good o-line with multiple weapons. Ask the JC fans if they remember the season opener against Ashland during Beach's senior year?

 

And we could ask the Ashland fans if they remember the 2nd half of the playoff game at Rockcastle a few years ago. I was there and remember it well. Beach was excellent in the first half and carried the Tomcats on his back to lead Rock. But the 2nd half, the Rockets shut him down and went on to win the game.

 

If you want to start a thread on West vs Beach, go for it, but don't be a hijacker dude! That is just dismissive of Blume and he deserves better than that.

Isn't Beach currently with the Packers right now?

Yes Beach is curently in the active roster. He is actually #1 in the Depth chart.

Yes Beach is curently in the active roster. He is actually #1 in the Depth chart.

 

 

:banana: :banana: :banana: :ylsuper: :ylsuper: :ylsuper:

 

Thats great for Arliss.

 

Not he that he would say it , but I hope a lot of people are noticing ;)

 

Big Tomcat Cheers, Woody Jr

:banana: :banana: :banana: :ylsuper: :ylsuper: :ylsuper:

 

Thats great for Arliss.

 

Not he that he would say it , but I hope a lot of people are noticing ;)

 

Big Tomcat Cheers, Woody Jr

:dancingpa :banana: :dancingpa :ylsuper: :dancingpa :banana: :ylsuper:

I hope Arliss does very well with the Packers! Anytime a KY boy gets a shot, I like to see them make the most of it!!! :thumb: