Tony Gwynn is Mr Padre without question.

 

Who gets the "Mister...." designation for other MLB teams?

I'll start with an easy one.

 

Ernie Banks is Mr Cub.

I'd argue Pete is Mr Red.

Roberto Clemente is Mr. Pirate

Henry Aaron is Mr. Brave

Willie Mays for SF Giants.

So many to pick from for the Yankees.

Cardinals, Stan the Man Musial

So many to pick from for the Yankees.

 

I'd agree to an extent, but in the end, that face belongs to The Babe, right?

Todd Helton - Rockies

Kirby Puckett - Twins

Robin Yount - Brewers

George Brett - Royals

Randy Johnson - Diamondbacks

Kirby Puckett's big grinning face for the Minnesota Twins.

Mike Schmidt or Steve Carlton for the Phillies?

Jeff Bagwell or Craig Biggio for the Astros?

Probably Frank Thomas for the White Sox.

 

I'd love to say Luis Aparicio, but truth be told, I don't know that I could pick him out of a lineup.

Mike Schmidt or Steve Carlton for the Phillies?

Without a doubt, Mike Schmidt. I would rate Richie Ashburn ahead of Carlton, because of his HOF playing career and even longer broadcasting career.