1st Team:

 

QB: Drew Ellison CCH

RB: Adams(Bellevue), Sawyer(Beechwood)

TE: Guidugli (HHS)

WR: Durbin(Conner) Bovard (CCH)

OL: Abell(HHS), Atchley(Dixie), Damico(SK), Davis(Boone), Janning(Beechwood)

PK: Roch (CCH)

 

2nd Team:

 

QB: Diehl (NC)

RB: Farris(Boone), Gray(Ryle)

TE: Atkins (Newport)

WR: Canafax (NC), Madlom (Ryle), Thomas (Newport)

OL: Ashworth (Ryle), Hammons(Conner), Riley(Bellevue), Schneider(NC), Spradlin(CCH), Young(Newport)

PK: Bathiany(HHS)

What no defense?

Defense:

 

1st Team

 

DL: Atchley(Dixie), Hobbs(Campbell), Meade(Ryle), Smith(NC)

LB: Kammer(Boone), Murray(Ryle), Sauerback(Campbell)

DB: Babik(Ryle), Durbin(Conner), Huenefeld(Dixie), Schiesler(HHS)

P: Gesenhues(NC)

 

2nd team

 

DL: Carl(Beechwood), Pryse(HHS), Reilly(Beechwood), Spradlin(CCH)

LB: Beck(HHS), McGee(CCH), Stone(Conner)

DB: Gray(Ryle), Sawyer(Beechwood), Schmitz(Bellevue), Sutton(CCH)

P: Wilfong(Newport)

Anyone else besides me see one glaring omission?

IMO, Farris is 1st team back. If you made me pick, I'd put him in over Sawyer(a fine back).

Lance Durbin...first team WR???????

 

Of course, I am biased, but there is no way he should have been selected over Canafax!!!!

 

:eek:

Lance Durbin...first team WR???????

 

Of course, I am biased, but there is no way he should have been selected over Canafax!!!!

 

:eek:

 

F4, I knew that was coming.

 

I guess it shows the amazing depth at the WR position in NKY. You cannot punish Durbin for Conner's offensive struggles. Unless he was dropping passes, he cannot be punished. Is he better? I don't know. I only saw each play one or two games. I'd take both on my team and be confident in my chances of attaining the W.

This is obviously a very subjective selection process. What criteria do coaches use in making these nominations??

 

For example, Canafax is one of 10 players nominated by local Media and Coaches to the KY. All State Team. Durbin and Bovard are not on that list!!!

 

This does not make any sense... :confused:

If you just looked at stats you would never know it but IMHO Lance Durbin is the best WR I have seen this year.

ashworth (OL) and meade (DL) from Ryle, but not Broadus (OL/DL)?

Sounds like politics to me...

ashworth (OL) and meade (DL) from Ryle, but not Broadus (OL/DL)?

Sounds like politics to me...

 

 

Please. Don't bring crap like 'politics' into this.

 

Any time you have coaches voting, there are going to be issues. How many coaches get to see all of the players? Not many. Even then, its one week. It leads to decisions/votes that some would question. Its not politics.

Lance Durbin...first team WR???????

 

Of course, I am biased, but there is no way he should have been selected over Canafax!!!!

 

:eek:

 

I have a bias as well. But I would say that there are not many WR's in NKY (maybe even KY for that matter) that can make plays like Lance did this season. I'm with you CSHS81, Lance shouldn't be punished for Conner's offensive struggles.

Because this is subjective it is not possible to have a logical discussion about this.....

 

For example, one argues not to penalize Durbin because of Conner's offensive woes...so you peanlize Canafax because he is a very important part/contributor to a strong offensive unit. Bottom line...he has delivered and performed, consistently I am just curious as to how this process works?? It obviously is not based exclusively on stats...so that leaves athletic ability and other intangibles.

 

If we agree on this, then how are these factors weighted? You mean to tell me that Durbin, and Bovard's skills, athletic ability, etc. are greater than Canafax's??? I have seen Bovard play, not Durbin (except on cable) I think they are pretty even relative to skills, ability, etc.

 

Canafax dropped 1 pass this year...1...out of 59 chances. Before anyone questions NCC competition he was only one of three receivers to have over 100 yards against CovCath.

 

At the end of the day this is not something to get worked up over. Everyone of the young men named to the first and second team are very deserving and are great athletes.

 

Thanks to everyone for letting me vent...

Hey what about that...Newport had 4 make 2nd team...great season cats...the players that made it had great seasons as well. Congrats to them

Defense:

 

1st Team

 

DL: Atchley(Dixie), Hobbs(Campbell), Meade(Ryle), Smith(NC)

LB: Kammer(Boone), Murray(Ryle), Sauerback(Campbell)

DB: Babik(Ryle), Durbin(Conner), Huenefeld(Dixie), Schiesler(HHS)

P: Gesenhues(NC)

 

2nd team

 

DL: Carl(Beechwood), Pryse(HHS), Reilly(Beechwood), Spradlin(CCH)

LB: Beck(HHS), McGee(CCH), Stone(Conner)

DB: Gray(Ryle), Sawyer(Beechwood), Schmitz(Bellevue), Sutton(CCH)

P: Wilfong(Newport)

 

Come on , folks. Nothing jumps out at you when you view this list?