All time Reds 25 man Roster

[Wildcat Dad]

I am bored, my satellite is out due to the rain .

Batting Order

1. Joe Morgan 2b 2. Pete Rose 3b 3. Dave Parker Rf 4.George Foster lf 5 Ken Griffey Jr. cf 6. Tony Perez 1b 7. Johny Bench C 8 Barry Larkin ss

 

Be nice to have a hitter like Larkin batting 8th

 

Reserves : C= Benito Santiago OF Eric Davis OF Ken Griffey SR 3b Chris Sabo SS= Dave Concepion (best defensive SS I ever saw ) OF Cesar Geronimo (as good as defensive Cf as there was ) Utility = Luis Quinones

 

Starting Pitcher 1 Tom Seaver Rh 2 Jose Rijo Rh 3 Don Gullett LH 4 Mario Soto Rh 5 Tom Browning LH

 

Relief Pitchers = Clay Carroll RH ,Rob Dibble RH, Randy Myers LH, Tom Hume Rh , Norm Charleton LH

 

Manager being Lou Pinella .

 

:thumb: I am sure they are some I forgot ,both that would be an A OK team .:banana:

[75center]

Um, Frank Robinson? Or did All time start in the 70's?

[Wildcat Dad]

Um, Frank Robinson? Or did All time start in the 70's?

 

He as a Red before my time , this was guys I have seen .:thumb:

[mexitucky]

Morgan wasn't a leadoff hitter.

 

All-time (taking guys in their primes)

LF Rose

SS Larkin

2B Morgan

1B Klu

RF Foster

C

[Mack The Knife]

My rotation would consist of Tom Seaver, Jim Maloney, Paul Derringer, Bucky Walters, and Don Gullett.

[malachicrunch]

I am bored, my satellite is out due to the rain .

Batting Order

1. Joe Morgan 2b 2. Pete Rose 3b 3. Dave Parker Rf 4.George Foster lf 5 Ken Griffey Jr. cf 6. Tony Perez 1b 7. Johny Bench C 8 Barry Larkin ss

 

Be nice to have a hitter like Larkin batting 8th

 

Reserves : C= Benito Santiago OF Eric Davis OF Ken Griffey SR 3b Chris Sabo SS= Dave Concepion (best defensive SS I ever saw ) OF Cesar Geronimo (as good as defensive Cf as there was ) Utility = Luis Quinones

 

Starting Pitcher 1 Tom Seaver Rh 2 Jose Rijo Rh 3 Don Gullett LH 4 Mario Soto Rh 5 Tom Browning LH

 

Relief Pitchers = Clay Carroll RH ,Rob Dibble RH, Randy Myers LH, Tom Hume Rh , Norm Charleton LH

 

Manager being Lou Pinella .

:thumb: I am sure they are some I forgot ,both that would be an A OK team .:banana:

 

I'd go with Sparky Anderson

[malachicrunch]

I am bored, my satellite is out due to the rain .

Batting Order

1. Joe Morgan 2b 2. Pete Rose 3b 3. Dave Parker Rf 4.George Foster lf 5 Ken Griffey Jr. cf 6. Tony Perez 1b 7. Johny Bench C 8 Barry Larkin ss

 

Be nice to have a hitter like Larkin batting 8th

 

Reserves : C= Benito Santiago OF Eric Davis OF Ken Griffey SR 3b Chris Sabo SS= Dave Concepion (best defensive SS I ever saw ) OF Cesar Geronimo (as good as defensive Cf as there was ) Utility = Luis Quinones

 

Starting Pitcher 1 Tom Seaver Rh 2 Jose Rijo Rh 3 Don Gullett LH 4 Mario Soto Rh 5 Tom Browning LH

 

Relief Pitchers = Clay Carroll RH ,Rob Dibble RH, Randy Myers LH, Tom Hume Rh , Norm Charleton LH

 

Manager being Lou Pinella .

 

:thumb: I am sure they are some I forgot ,both that would be an A OK team .:banana:

 

I'd go with Ernie Lombardi

[malachicrunch]

Morgan wasn't a leadoff hitter.

 

All-time (taking guys in their primes)

LF Rose

SS Larkin

2B Morgan

1B Klu

RF Foster

C

 

Foster played left

[Wildcat Dad]

Like I said mine was players that I have seen play ,Klu was before my time and I don't beklieve he could hit or drive in clutch runs like Tony Perez . Id still take B Santiago as back up catcher because the other guy was before my time .

[malachicrunch]

All-Time is kind of misleading then

[ladiesbballcoach]

My rotation would consist of Tom Seaver, Jim Maloney, Paul Derringer, Bucky Walters, and Don Gullett.

 

How do you leave out Mario Soto?

[ladiesbballcoach]

C Bench

1B Perez

2B Morgan

SS Larkin

3B Rose

LF Foster

CF Jr

RF Robinson

 

SP Seaver, Soto, Rijo, Maloney. I am old schooling with a 4-man rotation.

RP Hawk Clay Carroll, Rawly Eastwick, John Franco, the Nasty Boys Myers, Dibble and what was the LH's name?????

 

Assuming this is not just based on their time with the Reds, since so many are saying Seaver/Parker and his best years weren't with the Reds.

[Clyde]

Are we basing it solely on their time with the Reds?

[Wildcat Dad]

All-Time is kind of misleading then

 

My bad I see were u are coming from .

[Wildcat Dad]

C Bench

1B Perez

2B Morgan

SS Larkin

3B Rose

LF Foster

CF Jr

RF Robinson

 

SP Seaver, Soto, Rijo, Maloney. I am old schooling with a 4-man rotation.

RP Hawk Clay Carroll, Rawly Eastwick, John Franco, the Nasty Boys Myers, Dibble and what was the LH's name?????

 

Assuming this is not just based on their time with the Reds, since so many are saying Seaver/Parker and his best years weren't with the Reds.

 

Norm Charlton :thumb: