November 24, 200916 yr ^Him and AD have definitely separated themselves from the rest of the pack. I agree. I think AP is way in front of Johnson, but I think Johnson is way in front of everyone else. JMO.
November 24, 200916 yr I agree. I think AP is way in front of Johnson, but I think Johnson is way in front of everyone else. JMO. AD
November 25, 200916 yr I agree. I think AP is way in front of Johnson, but I think Johnson is way in front of everyone else. JMO. AP is really good but is fumble prone. I'd say because of that CJ is right there with him...
November 25, 200916 yr AP is really good but is fumble prone. I'd say because of that CJ is right there with him... You're probably right. I just think that All Day has the most potential of any RB I've seen. :thumb:
November 26, 200916 yr AP is really good but is fumble prone. I'd say because of that CJ is right there with him... Peterson is more powerful...where else is he better than Johnson? Ball security, receiving, pass protection, speed...all favor CJ. Just saying... And, I think there are several great backs at the top... Johnson, Peterson, Williams, MJD, and Steven Jackson are all comparable. AD hasn't separated himself from those guys. If you want to argue he's #1, fine...you could make an argument for any of them. But to rate the RB's like the QB's with Brady and Manning clearly distanced from the rest is not accurate, IMO.
November 26, 200916 yr You're probably right. I just think that All Day has the most potential of any RB I've seen. :thumb: Are we rating based on potential or results? Besides that, when can we expect him to reach his potential...?
November 26, 200916 yr :laugh:Where does it stop:confused: I think I could narrow it to 5 if I had to...but there's 2 or 3 more that could possibly be there.
November 26, 200916 yr Bironas has one heck of a leg. He is one of the best in the game today. Additionally, it's crazy how the Colts had Vanderjet (Sp?) and he was the most accurate kicker (percentage wise) in the game. But he had a huge miss in the playoffs (I think) and they go out and get Vineterri (Sp?) and you haven't heard from Vanderjet since.
November 26, 200916 yr Peterson is more powerful...where else is he better than Johnson? Ball security, receiving, pass protection, speed...all favor CJ. Just saying... And, I think there are several great backs at the top... Johnson, Peterson, Williams, MJD, and Steven Jackson are all comparable. AD hasn't separated himself from those guys. If you want to argue he's #1, fine...you could make an argument for any of them. But to rate the RB's like the QB's with Brady and Manning clearly distanced from the rest is not accurate, IMO. I can agree with this for the most part.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.