May 21, 200917 yr Underwood and Clarkson are definitely 1 & 2. IMHO, Daughtry has moved into that #3 slot after just one album and could overtake Clarkson if his 2nd album has near the success of his first one. I just think that Underwood has so much crossover appeal, it will be hard for any AI contestant to overtake her.
May 21, 200917 yr I would say you have to go with, in this order: Carrie Underwood Kelly Clarkson Daughtry Kellie Pickler Ruben Clay Aiken Fantasia Josh Gracin
May 21, 200917 yr The recent idol contestants Underwood 14 mil Hudson 5 mil Cook 2 mil Archuleta 1.3 mil
May 21, 200917 yr Daughtry, Clarkson and Underwood.....not necessarily in that oder. Adam will not out sell or make more money than those three. Imo. :thumb: Agree.
May 21, 200917 yr I would say you have to go with, in this order: Carrie Underwood Kelly Clarkson Daughtry Kellie Pickler Ruben Clay Aiken Fantasia Josh Gracin How do you leave Jordin Sparks off? Her debut album went platinum I believe. She had many hit songs such as "Tattoo", "No Air", and "One Step at a Time". She's far past Fantasia, Clay, Ruben, Josh, and Kelly IMO.
May 21, 200917 yr I would say you have to go with, in this order: Carrie Underwood Kelly Clarkson Daughtry Kellie Pickler Ruben Clay Aiken Fantasia Josh Gracin I would have Hudson 4 and Sparks 5 with Pickler just behind them at 6. I would have Aiken 7, Gracin 8, Studdard 9 and Fantasia 10. I agree with an earlier post that Daughtry will move to #2 if his second CD does anything like his first. IMHO.
May 21, 200917 yr I would have Hudson 4 and Sparks 5 with Pickler just behind them at 6. I would have Aiken 7, Gracin 8, Studdard 9 and Fantasia 10. I agree with an earlier post that Daughtry will move to #2 if his second CD does anything like his first. IMHO. I don’t know. I think William Hung has had more success than some of the past winners like Fantasia, Studdard, and Hicks.
May 21, 200917 yr I don’t know. I think William Hung has had more success than some of the past winners like Fantasia, Studdard, and Hicks. Probably so.:lol: I only put Fantasia 10th because of her success on Broadway. Studdard, well heck, he could be a great Luther Vandross successor.
May 21, 200917 yr The recent idol contestants Underwood 14 mil Hudson 5 mil Cook 2 mil Archuleta 1.3 mil Daughtry is somewhere between 5-6 mil on his 1 album
May 21, 200917 yr Some major AI fans on here, I feel out of place. But just from what I know I don't think anyone can surpass the success of Carrie Underwood, and that goes for the next five seasons of idol. Also don't think any of the contestants can match the hottness.
May 21, 200917 yr Some major AI fans on here, I feel out of place. But just from what I know I don't think anyone can surpass the success of Carrie Underwood, and that goes for the next five seasons of idol. Also don't think any of the contestants can match the hottness. I gotta give you that. She is nice to look at and has a voice to go with it! The total package!
May 21, 200917 yr How do you leave Jordin Sparks off? Her debut album went platinum I believe. She had many hit songs such as "Tattoo", "No Air", and "One Step at a Time". She's far past Fantasia, Clay, Ruben, Josh, and Kelly IMO. I completely forgot about Sparks!
May 21, 200917 yr Some major AI fans on here, I feel out of place. But just from what I know I don't think anyone can surpass the success of Carrie Underwood, and that goes for the next five seasons of idol. Also don't think any of the contestants can match the hottness. :thumb:
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.