You don't think her being an HC grad and calling games like that against Holmes don't go hand in hand? You might not agree with me, but that's just my opinion.

 

I honestly don't know the answer and have not seen one of her games: Are her total calls way out of balance against Holmes? In other words, do the other refs call like 10 fouls a game on Holmes and she is more like 20? Do her games with Holmes have a dissproportionate amount of calls against the Bulldogs. My guess is that is not the case statistically.

 

In addition, by your logic, if one graduated from a 9th region high school they are necessarily unable to call a fair game for anyone in the region except their's? I mean if Tom Freppon makes a series of bad calls against CCH or HHS, should we all assume he can't be fair because he's a New Cath guy? That would eliminate quite a few refs over the years. Maybe we just disagreed with his calls.

 

I'm not terribly concerned with this topic...you can rip her all you want. If you think she's bad have at it; you're entitled to your opinion. But to say or imply that a ref is intentionally biased or unfair is too much. You better have more info than she graduated from of another school 30 years go to throughing out those kind of accusations.

I honestly don't know the answer and have not seen one of her games: Are her total calls way out of balance against Holmes? In other words, do the other refs call like 10 fouls a game on Holmes and she is more like 20? Do her games with Holmes have a dissproportionate amount of calls against the Bulldogs. My guess is that is not the case statistically.

 

In addition, by your logic, if one graduated from a 9th region high school they are necessarily unable to call a fair game for anyone in the region except their's? I mean if Tom Freppon makes a series of bad calls against CCH or HHS, should we all assume he can't be fair because he's a New Cath guy? That would eliminate quite a few refs over the years. Maybe we just disagreed with his calls.

 

I'm not terribly concerned with this topic...you can rip her all you want. If you think she's bad have at it; you're entitled to your opinion. But to say or imply that a ref is intentionally biased or unfair is too much. You better have more info than she graduated from of another school 30 years go to throughing out those kind of accusations.

 

See my posts and the posts of others in this thread on the topic. You'll see that I never once implied that she she is intentionally biased or unfair but rather that in the games where she reffed and Holmes was playing, her calls left little to be desired. Unless you've actually seen a game that she reffed, you'll never truly understand where any of us are coming from.