Jump to content

Do They Deserve to be in the Hall of Fame?


Recommended Posts

Player A:

Has played 18 seasons

 

avg:.279

runs:1382

hits:1985

2B:384

HR:523

RBI:1442

BB:1507

 

Player B:

Has played 19 seasons

 

avg:.302

runs:1486

hits:2448

2B:493

HR:520

RBI:1701

BB:1654

 

Player C:

Has played 16 seasons

 

avg:.312

runs:1394

hits:2296

2B:487

HR:506

RBI:1658

BB:1167

 

Player D:

has played 16 seasons

 

avg:.295

runs:1061

hits:1936

2B:388

HR:434

RBI:1404

BB:457

 

4 guys with pretty comparable careers....Are any HoF worthy? See if you can guess who the mystery men are...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 40
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I'm so ashamed , Brett blows these guys out of the water. George if you are reading this I'm sorry.

 

Avg. .305

Runs 1583

hits 3154

2B 665

HR 317

RBI 1595

BB 1096

 

I think Manny's career numbers will surpass Brett's when he finally hangs them up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would vote yes on Thomas and Ramirez and no on Juan Gone and Thome, right now. While Thome and Gonzalez have good numbers otherwise I think their low hit numbers and sub .300 career averages work against them.

 

 

Is D Gonzalez? I know he tried to make a comeback with the Cardinals this year, but I didn't think he was still active.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm so ashamed , Brett blows these guys out of the water. George if you are reading this I'm sorry.

 

Avg. .305

Runs 1583

hits 3154

2B 665

HR 317

RBI 1595

BB 1096

 

He doesn't blow B and C out of the water.

Ramirez........Thomas.......Brett

avg:.312....... 302.......... .305

runs:1394...... 1486........ 1583

hits:2296....... 2448........ 3154

2B:487.......... 493.......... 665

HR:506.......... 520.......... 317

RBI:1658....... 1701......... 1595

BB:1167........ 1654......... 1096

 

The only catagories that he'll probably lead Ramirez in when he's done is hits and doubles. With Thomas it could be avg, hits runs, and doubles but he doesn't blow either one out of the water.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nope, A, B, & C are still active players...

 

A= Jim Thome

 

B= Frank Thomas

 

C= Manny Ramirez

 

D= Carlos Delgado

 

Is D Gonzalez? I know he tried to make a comeback with the Cardinals this year, but I didn't think he was still active.

 

He said A, B, and C--not all 4.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using the site you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use Policies.