1.  Otto Graham: 10 seasons played, 10 championship games, 7 championship games won.  Graham had his team in the championship game 100% of the seasons he played and won the championship 70% of seasons played.  

2.  Tom Brady: 22 seasons, 10 championship games, 7 championships won.  45% and 32%.  

3.  Joe Montana

4.  Johnny Unitas

5.  Peyton Manning

1. Brady: There was a time i would argue that Manning was better but lost that argument his last two super bowl wins.

2. Montana: Was there ever a QB smooth as this guy.

3. Unitas: 47 straight games with a TD pass back when you could hit the receivers before the ball is thrown is amazing!!

4. Manning: Best single caller of all time.

5. Marino: Fast draw in the west. Never had a solid D  

5 hours ago, tackle trap said:

1. Brady: There was a time i would argue that Manning was better but lost that argument his last two super bowl wins.

2. Montana: Was there ever a QB smooth as this guy.

3. Unitas: 47 straight games with a TD pass back when you could hit the receivers before the ball is thrown is amazing!!

4. Manning: Best single caller of all time.

5. Marino: Fast draw in the west. Never had a solid D  

OMAHA!

On 6/14/2022 at 9:18 PM, Bluegrasscard said:

Superbowl rings a factor?

1. Brady (7)

2. Montana (4)

3. Bradshaw (4)

4. Troy Aiken (3)

5. Payton Manning (2, 2 different teams)

 

 

 

 

 

No. Aikmen wasn't great in any way.

On 6/14/2022 at 9:18 PM, Bluegrasscard said:

Superbowl rings a factor?

1. Brady (7)

2. Montana (4)

3. Bradshaw (4)

4. Troy Aiken (3)

5. Payton Manning (2, 2 different teams)

 

 

 

 

 

Don’t forget to add that Brady just like Manning won a Super Bowl with two different teams too. 

11 hours ago, futurecoach said:

Don’t forget to add that Brady just like Manning won a Super Bowl with two different teams too. 

I thought if that.  But since he already had the top spot it was not a factor.  Somewhat a tie breaker since there is a log jam of two win QBs.