October 16, 20197 yr Rank the teams on this list the past 5 years: Team 1: Overall Record: 45-21 Bowl Record: 2-3 NY6 Bowl Record: 1-1 Top 10 Finishes: 2 Draft Picks: 24 Team 2: Overall Record: 53-15 Bowl Record: 5-0 NY6 Bowl Record: 2-0 Top 10 Finishes: 2 Draft Picks: 21 Team 3: Overall Record: 44-19 Bowl Record: 3-2 NY6 Bowl Record: 1-0 Top 10 Finishes: 1 Draft Picks: 36 Team 4: Overall Record: 41-25 Bowl Record: 2-3 NY6 Bowl Record: 0-2 Top 10 Finishes: 1 Draft Picks: 26 If there’s another stat you want that won’t give away who the team is let me know. None of these teams have ever made the playoff.
October 16, 20197 yr Rank the teams on this list the past 5 years: Team 1: Overall Record: 45-21 Bowl Record: 2-3 NY6 Bowl Record: 1-1 Top 10 Finishes: 2 Draft Picks: 24 Team 2: Overall Record: 53-15 Bowl Record: 5-0 NY6 Bowl Record: 2-0 Top 10 Finishes: 2 Draft Picks: 21 Team 3: Overall Record: 44-19 Bowl Record: 3-2 NY6 Bowl Record: 1-0 Top 10 Finishes: 1 Draft Picks: 36 Team 4: Overall Record: 41-25 Bowl Record: 2-3 NY6 Bowl Record: 0-2 Top 10 Finishes: 1 Draft Picks: 26 If there’s another stat you want that won’t give away who the team is let me know. None of these teams have ever made the playoff. Team 2 Team 3 Team 1 Team 4
October 16, 20197 yr Author How are we ranking? Just the one that looks the most attractive to us? Can you add SOS? Yeah just which one you think is better. I’ll put together an average of the SOS.
October 16, 20197 yr Author SOS Average Over 5 Years: Team 1: 24.6 Team 2: 31 Team 3: 14.6 Team 4: 9.6 I should have included this stat at the beginning.
October 16, 20197 yr Author My side of the argument is team 2 has hands down been better, teams 1 and 3 are indistinguishable, and team 4 shouldn’t be included in the same discussion with the other 3 schools.
October 16, 20197 yr My side of the argument is team 2 has hands down been better, teams 1 and 3 are indistinguishable, and team 4 shouldn’t be included in the same discussion with the other 3 schools. I mostly agree, minus #2's SOS.
October 16, 20197 yr Author I mostly agree, minus #2's SOS. What if I told you 3 and 2 played twice in the past 5 years and each team won once? Both at neutral sites and both close games.
October 16, 20197 yr Team #2 has some gaudy numbers, but they are making a championship game every year, so I'm guessing they are in a 2nd tier conference (especially considering their lack of draftees).
October 16, 20197 yr What if I told you 3 and 2 played twice in the past 5 years and each team won once? Both at neutral sites and both close games. I would tell you Team #3 is in a power 5 league, a really good (but not elite) program, with so-so coaching but great athletes. Team #2 is from a non-power league, a bit of a darling with a coach who is well thought of, but not producing a ton of high-end players. My two cents.
October 16, 20197 yr What if I told you 3 and 2 played twice in the past 5 years and each team won once? Both at neutral sites and both close games. I'd still give #3 the slight edge.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.