July 21, 20179 yr 1. Lawrence Taylor 2. Frank Gifford 3. Rosey Brown 4. Emlen Tummel 5. Harry Carson 6. YA Tittle 7. Michael Strahan 8. Phil Simms 9. Sam Huff 10. Andy Robustelli
July 24, 20179 yr Did you mean Rosie Greer? Roosevelt Brown is whom he meant, I believe. OT in the 50's and 60's. Rosey Grier was a Giant and a Ram, DT, and was a killer with needle point. He also is a minister.
July 25, 20179 yr No way you can have a Giants list without Eli on it. It's possible with historic franchises to leave a lot of greats off.
July 25, 20179 yr It's possible with historic franchises to leave a lot of greats off. Exactly. Who do you take off the top ten list provided in post #2 to include Eli?
July 25, 20179 yr Exactly. Who do you take off the top ten list provided in post #2 to include Eli? Don't know who a lot of them are, but without question Phil Simms would definitely be one.
July 30, 20179 yr Don't know who a lot of them are, but without question Phil Simms would definitely be one. I love Phil, but I agree. Eli is on the list. He is a 2 time super bowl MVP and will hold every Giants record when he's done.
July 30, 20179 yr Tough list to make...#1 is easy though. 1.) LT Not ranked, here are the rest imo... Eli Manning Michael Strahan Harry Carson Emlen Tunnel Rosey Brown Sam Huff Frank Gifford Andy Robustelli Mel Hein Outside looking in... YA Tittle Tiki Barber Arnold Weinmeister George Martin Steve Owen Phil Simms
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.