Antonio Brown Records Tomlin Post Game

[GrantNKY]

Taller? Being taller?

quicker and faster too.

[Voice of Reason]

Go look at the numbers. Take their best 5 years and AB beats Ocho in every category. Catches, TDS, yards.

 

He never caught over 100 balls. AB has what....4 or 5 times?

 

AB scores more, gets more yards and catches more TDS. What else could he do to be better?

 

Statistically at this point in their careers, it is pretty close. Brown has more receptions, but yards are about the same giving Chad a higher yards per catch average. TD's about the same. Receptions longer than 40 yards about the same. I give the edge to Brown as a WR but it isn't a no brainer. Where Brown really separates himself from Chad as a player is with the added punt return factor.

[UKMustangFan]

AB is slower, shorter, and doesn't have the body control Chad had. It's not that subjective.

 

Wrong. He isn't slower.

[GrantNKY]

Let's see AB is quicker. AB is a better route runner. AB has better hands. AB is a more physical receiver. AB is more athletic....What exactly is/was Chad better at???

Chad is better at all of those except maybe route running.

[GrantNKY]

Wrong. He isn't slower.

Yes he is.

[UKMustangFan]

quicker and faster too.

 

Wrong.

[halfback20]

AB is slower, shorter, and doesn't have the body control Chad had. It's not that subjective.

 

Google tells me AB ran a 4.47 40 yard dash. Ocho ran a 4.57. Next you will say Ocho is quicker...

[UKMustangFan]

Yes he is.

 

So a 4.57 40 is quicker than a 4.47?

 

In what world?

[GrantNKY]

AB can do things Ocho couldn't do. Like catch more passes, for more yards and more TDs

Again that is a production thing, not a talent thing.

[UKMustangFan]

Chad is better at all of those except maybe route running.

 

To a Bengals fan I'm sure he was....To unbiased fans looking at it objectively, Brown is better in all of them.

[bugatti]

They're just prisoners of the moment. Chad is top 5 all time as far as pure talent goes. All of the other stuff brings him down and rightfully so, but Chad flat out balled until his ego got the best of him.

You are normally out there at times, and that is cool. But making the argument Chad was a top 5 WR talent of all time is probably your best work. While I am not saying Chad was a fantasy creation, he rose to prominence as fantasy football was exploding, making people believe he was far superior than he really was. And he was great, just not that great.

[GrantNKY]

So a 4.57 40 is quicker than a 4.47?

 

In what world?

Chad is faster I don't care about 40 speed. Run the 40 in full pads with someone covering you.

[GrantNKY]

To a Bengals fan I'm sure he was....To unbiased fans looking at it objectively, Brown is better in all of them.

Again prisoner of the moment. No way I win this argument considering Chads prime was 10 years ago.

[UKMustangFan]

Chad is faster I don't care about 40 speed. Run the 40 in full pads with someone covering you.

 

:lol2: This is comical. I don't know why I even bother. Factual evidence exists that shows you're wrong and you can't even see it because your too blinded by your fandom and personal bias. I'm out. Not worth it.

[GrantNKY]

You make me pick a receiver to have on my team I'm going AB because he produces more. Chad is still more talented.