Well Hamilton did not win. DBacks Pollock wins.

Reds were shut out.

Catcher

NL: Yadier Molina, Cardinals (eighth straight win)

AL: Salvador Perez, Royals (third straight)

 

Shortstop

NL: Brandon Crawford, Giants (first)

AL: Alcides Escobar, Royals (first)

 

First base

NL: Paul Goldschmidt, D-backs (second)

AL: Eric Hosmer, Royals (third straight)

 

Second base

NL: Dee Gordon, Marlins (first)

AL: Jose Altuve, Astros (first)

 

Third base

NL: Nolan Arenado, Rockies (third straight)

AL: Manny Machado, Orioles (second)

 

Left field

NL: Starling Marte, Pirates (first)

AL: Yoenis Cespedes, Tigers (first)

 

Center field

NL: A.J. Pollock, D-backs (first)

AL: Kevin Kiermaier, Rays (first)

 

Right field

NL: Jason Heyward, Cardinals (second straight, third overall)

AL: Kole Calhoun, Angels (first)

 

Pitcher

AL: Dallas Keuchel, Astros (second straight)

I didn't get to see Pollock much, but I can't imagine someone playing a much better CF than Hamilton.

Phillips also had a good year and some amazing plays.

I didn't get to see Pollock much, but I can't imagine someone playing a much better CF than Hamilton.

 

Just looking at the stats, I wonder if Hamilton got penalized somewhat for missing some games. Pollack had him by over 375 innings. That translated to 355 chances versus 281. So, I'd understand all of that, but Pollack also had 3 errors while Hamilton had zero.

 

Oh yeah, Pollack also batted .315 while Hamilton was only hitting .226.

If you get penalized for missing games Molina wouldnt have couple of his gold gloves, I have always hated the way the decide these. Phillips has been robbed a couple times for sure, I have got to where I get mad before I even look at the results

No errors and still didnt win the gold glove, how nuts is that, Phillips makes plays that only he can make and gets no respect for them

Phillips doesn't have the same range he used to have.

Just looking at the stats, I wonder if Hamilton got penalized somewhat for missing some games. Pollack had him by over 375 innings. That translated to 355 chances versus 281. So, I'd understand all of that, but Pollack also had 3 errors while Hamilton had zero.

 

Oh yeah, Pollack also batted .315 while Hamilton was only hitting .226.

 

I wasn't aware batting gloves were also taken into consideration.

I wasn't aware batting gloves were also taken into consideration.

 

Unfortunately, I think that's happened on many occasions. Voters confuse "having a good season overall", with being the best defender.

I will never understand why any fan gets upset over this kind of stuff.