November 9, 200916 yr How many losses does your team have to have to have you eliminated as a candidate? Great question. The fact that their numbers are similar and Tebow is on a national title contender in a better conference makes him the obvious choice between these two.
November 9, 200916 yr Cylde's point will be that Pryor and Tebow's numbers are similar or in Pryor's favor. If I would have realized he had started the thread, I would have realized there was a hidden motive or agenda. :thumb:
November 9, 200916 yr SOS would seem to disagree with that sentiment. How SOS is figured is comical. You look at the schedule and tell me who plays a tougher one.
November 9, 200916 yr SOS would seem to disagree with that sentiment. So now the Big Ten is as good as the SEC....:lol: :lol:
November 9, 200916 yr Who is the last Heisman winner that wasn't on a great team? And to rile up the tOSU fans... Troy Smith
November 9, 200916 yr I wouldn't take either of them this year. If Tebow wins, it is a career achievment award, he hasn't been that great this year (but who has?). The Heisman is talked about and debated...and I watch it every year, but there is no real criteria.
November 9, 200916 yr And to rile up the tOSU fans... Troy Smith :lol: Nice. To the Tebow one... he had out of this world numbers that year.
November 9, 200916 yr Author How SOS is figured is comical. You look at the schedule and tell me who plays a tougher one. Is it possible we've all fallen into the trap of assuming UF has played a tough schedule? Who have they played that's really tough so far? LSU with no qb? Is that the toughest team they've played? I'm a SEC homer but lets admit that its not the SEC of recent past.
November 9, 200916 yr Author If I would have realized he had started the thread, I would have realized there was a hidden motive or agenda. :thumb: Correct. My "agenda" was to get people to question an axiom. So, you're right. You busted me.
November 9, 200916 yr Is it possible we've all fallen into the trap of assuming UF has played a tough schedule? Who have they played that's really tough so far? LSU with no qb? Is that the toughest team they've played? I'm a SEC homer but lets admit that its not the SEC of recent past. They have both played average schedules. I think LSU is just as good as USC... outside of that the schedules are pretty similar. Plus, UF has Alabama waiting for them and OSU has Iowa at home for the Big 10 title. The Big 10 is bad.
November 9, 200916 yr Author They have both played average schedules. I think LSU is just as good as USC... outside of that the schedules are pretty similar. . So you'd agree then that based on everything so far that they're pretty close?
November 9, 200916 yr So you'd agree then that based on everything so far that they're pretty close? So far... and UF has Alabama left.
November 9, 200916 yr I'll take Tim Tebow, he hasn't lost his team any games this season, and even put his team on his back and won a couple. Pryor has gotten better this season, but I don't think you can make a legitimate argument that justifies him-Pryor-getting a Heisman vote over Tebow. That's just my opinion. But in the end I'm going to say Colt McCoy wins it.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.