June 30, 200917 yr How does Eli not even get considered? Rivers makes it but Eli isn't even considered? Romo is considered but Eli isn't? I didn't even think about that, but you are exactly right.
June 30, 200917 yr I would take Fritz over Johnson. Troy Polamalu should be higher. Merriman is better than Ware. Warner is better than Palmer. I would take Eli over Romo. He's definitely got more hype and press. Whether he's actually better is up for debate. Ware has tallied more tackles than Merriman every season. He had more sacks in '07 when both guys were healthy. His career high of 20 (last season) tops Merriman's best (17 in '06). Ware has a better average of sacks per season, 13.4 to 13.2. (Merriman gets the edge per 16 games...14.7-13.4). Ware forces more TO's. Considering that Ware is statistically better in almost every area and he's not coming back from a serious injury, I'll take him.
June 30, 200917 yr I've got a question for Steelers fans who think Polamalu should be higher. Who do you think the best defensive player on the team is? Do you think Harrison is better than Polamalu? If you could only have one of them, just for one season, ignoring age, who would you keep? I ask, because I think Polamalu is the best player on the Steelers defense. And, by default, should be rated ahead of Harrison on any list.
June 30, 200917 yr Author I've got a question for Steelers fans who think Polamalu should be higher. Who do you think the best defensive player on the team is? Do you think Harrison is better than Polamalu? If you could only have one of them, just for one season, ignoring age, who would you keep? I ask, because I think Polamalu is the best player on the Steelers defense. And, by default, should be rated ahead of Harrison on any list. I do too. Only Ed Reed is ahead of Polamalu in my book in terms of Defensive players
June 30, 200917 yr I've got a question for Steelers fans who think Polamalu should be higher. Who do you think the best defensive player on the team is? Do you think Harrison is better than Polamalu? If you could only have one of them, just for one season, ignoring age, who would you keep? I ask, because I think Polamalu is the best player on the Steelers defense. And, by default, should be rated ahead of Harrison on any list. I would put Polamalu ahead of Harrison. If I had to choose one, I would pick Troy without hesitation...
June 30, 200917 yr Just curious...to me, that's what stood out more than anything about his ranking. He wasn't even #1 on his team.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.