October 27, 200718 yr Author I watched Matt Ryan throw bad passes for over 3 quarters Wednesday night. He has not shown me any consistency. Dixon and Tebow can run the ball well and that is a whole new element, but neither are the passer Woodson is. Brohm and Woodson is a good argument, but I truly believe Woodson has played better than Brohm this year and I give him the nod. But look at the weather at that game, Ryan hasn't played in weather like that all year. Plus look what the guy done in the last couple of minutes. Tebow and Dixon are also good passers, not just runners. Brohm has played better IMO, just his D has let him down all year long.
October 27, 200718 yr Author :thumb: And also, he should win 5-7 super bowls and 7-9 MVP's in the NFL.
October 27, 200718 yr And also, he should win 5-7 super bowls and 7-9 MVP's in the NFL. No doubter! :walk:
October 27, 200718 yr Author We are having this conversation AGAIN? I just wanted to know what people thought. I think he is in the top 10 players and top 4 QB's and I was wondering what everyone else thought.
October 27, 200718 yr But look at the weather at that game, Ryan hasn't played in weather like that all year. Plus look what the guy done in the last couple of minutes. Tebow and Dixon are also good passers, not just runners. Brohm has played better IMO, just his D has let him down all year long. Thats part of it. No one used that as an excuse with the rain in the South Carolina game. Ryan was impressive in the last 2 minutes, but he hasn't been as good as Woodson for the season. Tebow and Dixon are both good passers, I just don't think they are as good as of passers as Woodson, although theya re great runners. And I think Woodson is better.
October 27, 200718 yr Author Thats part of it. No one used that as an excuse with the rain in the South Carolina game. Ryan was impressive in the last 2 minutes, but he hasn't been as good as Woodson for the season. Tebow and Dixon are both good passers, I just don't think they are as good as of passers as Woodson, although theya re great runners. And I think Woodson is better. Woodson is better passers than Tebow and Dixon, but those two are still very, very good. Woodson is a good QB, I just like the other guys more than Woodson.
October 27, 200718 yr One of the best. I don't think there is a clear cut best this year. If I had to have one QB to put my team in the best plays then Woodson would be my guy. If I had to have one player that has done it over time then Brohm would be my guy. If I had to have one guy to spread the field and bowl over people plus set up nasty play action Tebow would be my guy. If I had to pick the most underrated Dixon would be my guy. If I had to take the best tandem the White/Slayton would be my guys. If I had to take one guy to build my team around the McFadden would be my guy. Anymore questions:)
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.