December 4, 200619 yr "It was the fourth consecutive loss for the Giants (6-6) and the fifth victory in six games for Dallas (8-4) since Romo replaced Drew Bledsoe at quarterback at halftime of a 36-22 loss to New York on Oct. 23. He finished 20-for-34 for 257 yards with two interceptions."
December 4, 200619 yr "It was the fourth consecutive loss for the Giants (6-6) and the fifth victory in six games for Dallas (8-4) since Romo replaced Drew Bledsoe at quarterback at halftime of a 36-22 loss to New York on Oct. 23. He finished 20-for-34 for 257 yards with two interceptions." I think it was clear who the better QB was tonight...
December 4, 200619 yr So? When you have 10 penalties for over 100 yards, what do you expect? It was not Eli's fault at all, it was mostly on the Giants secondary. Mainly Will Demps for having the tackling skills of an 8 year old. The Giants had 9 for 94 yards
December 4, 200619 yr Who's that ? Did you not watch the game? It was quite obvious who had the better night.
December 4, 200619 yr Author Did you not watch the game? It was quite obvious who had the better night. Better night and better QB are 2 different things.
December 4, 200619 yr Better night and better QB are 2 different things. How anyone could claim Tony Romo is better than Eli Manning at this point is beyond me. He's played in what, 6 games? And he's struggled in 2-3 of those. Vs the Giants the first time he was anything but impressive, vs Washington he didnt play that well and tonight he did nothing to overly impress me aside from a few nice throws.
December 4, 200619 yr Author How anyone could claim Tony Romo is better than Eli Manning at this point is beyond me. He's played in what, 6 games? And he's struggled in 2-3 of those. Vs the Giants the first time he was anything but impressive, vs Washington he didnt play that well and tonight he did nothing to overly impress me aside from a few nice throws. And Eli has been anything but impressive for his career so far.
December 4, 200619 yr And Eli has been anything but impressive for his career so far. While he's struggled at times, I'd say he's been very impressive at times. Including numerous 4th quarter comebacks.
December 4, 200619 yr Author While he's struggled at times, I'd say he's been very impressive at times. Including numerous 4th quarter comebacks. But not overall.
December 4, 200619 yr But not overall. There isn't a QB out there who played every game perfect, especially inside of his first 3 years. A lot was expected out of Eli, and he just hasn't been up to everyone's standards. I think he's going to be a fine quarterback and I'm glad he's a New York Giant.
December 4, 200619 yr How anyone could claim Tony Romo is better than Eli Manning at this point is beyond me. He's played in what, 6 games? And he's struggled in 2-3 of those. Vs the Giants the first time he was anything but impressive, vs Washington he didnt play that well and tonight he did nothing to overly impress me aside from a few nice throws. Romo has started 5 games...In those 5 games, here are his stats.. 125/180 1656 Yards 13 TD 5 INT 110.5 QB Rating Eli has started 11 games...In those 11 games, here are his stats.. 211/362 2345 Yards 17 TD 15 INT 76.0 QB Rating Romo is only 689 Yards behind Eli in passing yards & Eli has started 6 more games than Romo Romo is only 2 TD's behind Eli in TD passes & Eli has played 6 more games than Romo QB Rating
December 4, 200619 yr Author There isn't a QB out there who played every game perfect, especially inside of his first 3 years. A lot was expected out of Eli, and he just hasn't been up to everyone's standards. I think he's going to be a fine quarterback and I'm glad he's a New York Giant. Ok I agree. nice job side steeping the real argument though.
December 4, 200619 yr Romo has started 5 games...In those 5 games, here are his stats.. 125/180 1656 Yards 13 TD 5 INT 110.5 QB Rating Eli has started 11 games...In those 11 games, here are his stats.. 211/362 2345 Yards 17 TD 15 INT 76.0 QB Rating Romo is only 689 Yards behind Eli in passing yards & Eli has started 6 more games than Romo Romo is only 2 TD's behind Eli in TD passes & Eli has played 6 more games than Romo QB Rating Look at tonights game, tell me who was more impressive. When Eli's on...Romo isn't near him talent wise. Also, Eli is ahead by FOUR touchdowns...not two. Easy math. 17-13=4
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.